Welcome to one of the most active flamenco sites on the Internet. Guests can read most posts but if you want to participate click here to register.
This site is dedicated to the memory of Paco de Lucía, Ron Mitchell, Guy Williams, Linda Elvira, Philip John Lee, Craig Eros, Ben Woods, David Serva and Tom Blackshear who went ahead of us.
We receive 12,200 visitors a month from 200 countries and 1.7 million page impressions a year. To advertise on this site please contact us.
Anyone else noticed changes in fingers when comparing left hand with right after years or decades of guitar playing, for example, pinky finger being longer on left hand and index and middle fingers slightly bent towards the ring finger from the middle up, while left hand index and middle fingers are straight(improved shape for picking strings I think)
Just curious how the body adapts to the instrument
Posts: 15334
Joined: Dec. 14 2004
From: Washington DC
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to tele)
It is your imagination guys, sorry. You did not take data before to compare to now so you have a bias. My friend tried to claim this about himself some 30 years ago, so I have been observing my own hands. No, it is in your mind.
Maybe you guys saw that movie the illusionist? He does a trick with his back turned asked the lady to hold up her hand to her head with the coin in it to “project it” to him mentally. Then put her hand to her sides…he turns and guesses the correct hand. How? The blood pools up in the hand that dangled, so the darker hand did NOT have the coin. I realize that the situation of guitar makes some guitar players superficially look like the right hand has beefed up and the left looks more normal, but it is an illusion of the blood flow that just balances out later.
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to Ricardo)
My left hand fingers are actually slightly longer too. Never noticed this before playing guitar, only noticed this few months ago. I wish I could take a picture
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to tele)
quote:
anyone else has bent slightly towards the ring finger, up from the middle joint?
Mine are like that. I’m right handed. On the left, the middle’s fairly straight and the index and ring curve toward it after the middle joint. On the right, the ring’s fairly straight, and the index and middle curve toward it. The curves are more pronounced on my right hand. On both hands, the nails are off center (a little closer to the side away from the thumb). Extended, they look pretty ugly but everything seems to line up right when they’re bent in playing position.
I think Ricardo’s right. I’ve seen photos of Sabicas with fat, gnarly fingers, but I think it was just his old age when the photo was taken.
Short fingers on plump hands seem to get the most consistent results. Melchor and many others. The thing is, Paco had long (and maybe twisted) fingers, and nobody has played as well as he did.
Posts: 15334
Joined: Dec. 14 2004
From: Washington DC
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to metalhead)
quote:
ORIGINAL: metalhead
My left hand fingers are actually slightly longer too. Never noticed this before playing guitar, only noticed this few months ago. I wish I could take a picture
Like i said, I have been running this experiment for 30 years now, before I was even playing flamenco proper (I used a pick back then). My RIGHT HAND pinky is still larger than my left hand pinky since I noticed it as a kid. Fingers are curved on both hands, etc. My hands are fatter only. My favorite YouTube comment after having posted videos for a decade or more, some guy said “Every new video this guy puts up he gets fatter. Doesn’t he know going to the gym doesn’t bother the hands??”
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to tele)
No I have not but I have noticed the tip of my left hand index finger now leans away from the middle finger. I noticed it about 2 years after I started to play flamenco. It is my contention that it is due to all the stretches from finger movement when playing barre with the index finger. Has this occurred to anybody else?
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to metalhead)
quote:
My left hand fingers are actually slightly longer too.
Maybe they always were, but if you are sure not, then it is the calluses that can make them appear longer. But no, guitar playing does not change the length of your fingers unless you are a kid who is still growing (even then it is just a correlation, not a causation. Did you know that kids with larger feet are better readers?).
This all started with a Segovia myth that his left hand fingers became significantly longer than right hand fingers, by like a half inch/ centimetre. Not sure if he himself claimed that or someone misinterpreted a bad photo (or just made it up), but it was a "known fact" since the 1970s or even earlier..
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to tele)
Sooner or later everyone's fingers, particularly right hand fingers, will look fat and stiff. Reliable source: Encuentro video - Merengue de Cordoba and Gerardo Nunez.
Posts: 221
Joined: Mar. 17 2015
From: Virginia USA
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to tele)
The fingernails of my left hand are flatter compared to those on the right hand which are more tunnel-like shape. Is it caused by the pressure from the finger tips from years of playing?
Posts: 15334
Joined: Dec. 14 2004
From: Washington DC
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to Goldwinghai)
quote:
ORIGINAL: Goldwinghai
The fingernails of my left hand are flatter compared to those on the right hand which are more tunnel-like shape. Is it caused by the pressure from the finger tips from years of playing?
Do you ever use glue on your nails or some other product?
Posts: 221
Joined: Mar. 17 2015
From: Virginia USA
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to Ricardo)
I did use that stuff on both hands for a short time. My natural nails are very hard but when there was a chip on my right hand fingernail, I put a little super glue on it.
Posts: 1809
Joined: Nov. 8 2010
From: London (living in the Bay Area)
RE: Changes in guitarist's fingers (in reply to tele)
When I was young, my fingers were more flexible: I could play the usual A Major chord with just the first finger of my left hand, bending it back to avoid the first string.
I could do the same thing with my fourth finger on a B Major chord (but not with my third finger, for some reason).
However, they don’t bend backwards any more (although there’s no pain or any other problem).
Printable Version
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread