RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - General: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=13
- - - RE: "Which guitar do I play today???": http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=229795



Message


guitarbuddha -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 18:07:04)

quote:

ORIGINAL: aeolus



There may indeed be players here that could display Eugen Drabynka's control on
Sor's Study 6 op.6. But I doubt it.

Peace.



I was loathe to comment on that Sor performance but it is not a good example of classical guitar playing. The guy is young,confident talented and exuberant but that performance was really lacking in nuance.

With regards to Shiraz nothing aids the battle with windmills more.

D.




jshelton5040 -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 18:17:15)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lenador

I'm just saying I can execute techniques that a classical player can't no matter how good they are.

Lenador,

Do you realize that many people play flamenco and classical. I played flamenco for 45 years and classical for over 35 of that. Switching back and forth always seemed rather effortless to me. Among the many critiques of my playing I never heard anyone say that I played like a pantywaist.




Leñador -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 20:42:47)

quote:

Do you realize that many people play flamenco and classical. I played flamenco for 45 years and classical for over 35 of that. Switching back and forth always seemed rather effortless to me. Among the many critiques of my playing I never heard anyone say that I played like a pantywaist.


You're one of the good ones [:D] jk

I know most non-Spanish flamenco players come from a classical background, my teacher included. I'm just railing against the classical purists who think flamenco ha nothing to add to the nylon.

quote:

By the way, I'm glad you didn't accept Aeolus dare, it was a trap. You have a beard and therefore are not allowed to play Classical music, they don't accept that. Crossing legs while playing is not allowed too. Sorry for destroying your childhood dream of becoming a professional Classical guitarrist... It's better for you to know the truth... Things wouldn't work out...


That truth is too painful, I'm gunna go soak my beard with tears [:D]




Sr. Martins -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 20:49:25)

quote:

I'm just railing against the classical purists who think flamenco ha nothing to add to the nylon.



Flamenco sucks.

BTW, your inbox is full.




Leñador -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 20:54:09)

I didn't even know that was possible?!?

Makes sense though, dealt with yo.....




britguy -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 23:16:09)

quote:

Do you realize that many people play flamenco and classical. I played flamenco for 45 years and classical for over 35 of that. Switching back and forth always seemed rather effortless to me.


I'm the same, John.

I played flamenco for years before trying to play classical (self-taught). But I found the classical discipline helped my overall playing to some extent.

I don't see why there should be such a dichotomy between the two. I think they can be mutually complementary, for many players. And there is some really beautifull 'classical' guitar music out there.

I know a few popular older classical pieces: (Sor, Tarrega, Carcassi) that I really enjoy playing these days. But I do sincerely believe that flamenco is harder to play well, and the techniques are more difficult to master.

But here and now; in my later years; I find I enjoy the lyrical qualities of the toques libres more than the sparkle and vigour of the bailes. And there are times when these toques seems to overlap with the 'classical' guitar's sound and feel. . .

I dont see this as such a bad thing. . .

I was (still am) always a great admirer of Vicente Gomez, as a flamenco guitarist who could also play classical. Or should I say; a classical guitarist who could also play flamenco??? Depends on who's asking the question.

Maybe you have to be native-born Spanish to answer that?

Either way, I thought he was a great player.

And we should all be happy that we can play this stuff anyway. No matter how simple. It is really an uplifting experience. . .




jeff_hatcher -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 27 2013 23:35:01)

quote:

I don't see why there should be such a dichotomy between the two. I think they can be mutually complementary, for many players. And there is some really beautifull 'classical' guitar music out there.


Well said. Both have their challenges and their beauty. Toss in Jazz, folk, blues... no reason we can't uncritically enjoy most things.

Unless being critical is what you enjoy[;)]




JJ -> RE: "Which guitar do I play today???" (Apr. 28 2013 7:33:24)

conclusion of this topic:




Page: <<   <   6 7 8 9 [10]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET