Foro Flamenco


Posts Since Last Visit | Advanced Search | Home | Register | Login

Today's Posts | Inbox | Profile | Our Rules | Contact Admin | Log Out



Welcome to one of the most active flamenco sites on the Internet. Guests can read most posts but if you want to participate click here to register.

This site is dedicated to the memory of Paco de Lucía, Ron Mitchell, Guy Williams, Linda Elvira, Philip John Lee, Craig Eros, Ben Woods, David Serva and Tom Blackshear who went ahead of us.

We receive 12,200 visitors a month from 200 countries and 1.7 million page impressions a year. To advertise on this site please contact us.





fingernails   You are logged in as Guest
Users viewing this topic: none
  Printable Version
All Forums >>Discussions >>General >> Page: [1] 2    >   >>
Login
Message<< Newer Topic  Older Topic >>
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

fingernails 

Hi,
I am a recent beginner in flamenco guitar. Is there any advice on right hand fingernails length etc, please, including thumb.

My nails aren't too strong and tend to break too.

many thanks
davidj
Birmingham
UK

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 12:18:20
Guest

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

David

Try to keep your nails as short as possible, consistent with a good sound. This applies even to the thumb, provided you can get a good alzapua sound. Try to avoid the vice of long nails, which often lead to a spiral of breakages, glue reinforcement, weaker nails, more glue....disaster.

This is the advice of Roman Vicenti, accompanist of El Farriquito, who uses nothing to strengthen his nais except in emergency.

Sean
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 14:46:11
 
Miguel de Maria

Posts: 3532
Joined: Oct. 20 2003
From: Phoenix, AZ

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Another take on this is to use superglue or acrylic nails. Perhaps this is a vice, perhaps not. Paco uses some sort of stuff on his nails (but he probably has lots of vices too). My friend's nails used to be ground down to the skin (yes the skin under the nail) when he would play three gigs in a row. That's not good! So if you are going to be strumming a lot you might want to think about that. Myself, my nails were always a little weak and I felt they were a weakness to me, even when I played classical. When I first used acrylic nails, it felt so good to have strong nails that I could shape any way I want. Now I have had them for about 4 years and I love them! I don't agree that they significantly weaken the nail. My nails are the same strength as they have always been.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 15:24:00
 
Jim Opfer

Posts: 1876
Joined: Jul. 19 2003
From: Glasgow, Scotland.

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Hi David,

Depends on your nails and what you feel works best.
If you play a lot of flamenco you'll soon know what is best for you.
I play for dance quite a lot and when we practice, natural nails are fine, but in performance, I always burst my ring finger nail if I don't have paper and super glue on. The rest seem fine.

I agree with sean that your nails should be as short as possible.

Also helps to view the shape of your nail looking 'straight on' to the ends of your fingertips. Some people shape their nail looking down at them, but this is wrong. No point in having nice looking nails if they don't have a straight shape 'end on' as the strings see them.

Jim.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 15:54:09
Guest

[Deleted] (in reply to davidj

[Deleted by Admins]
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 15:55:13
 
crowduck

 

Posts: 4
Joined: Aug. 11 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to Guest

I have been using a product named Vitashell that has made a great improvement in my nails. It can be found in pet stores in the section for turtles and other hard shelled creatures. It is used to condition the shells of turtles, etc. It has made my nails much thicker and stronger without being brittle. It's about $5. I've also been trying garlic at the suggestion of a spanish luthier. He says to dig your nails into a clove of garlic twice a day for 2 weeks. I've been doing that and rubbing the garlic oil on my nails and cuticles. Don't know if it's making a difference yet, but I love garlic anyway. Maybe he is just having a little fun.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 20:24:18
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Many many thanks for the interesting replies from Sean, Miguel de Maria, Jim Opfer, nealf and crowduck ! I have read them all with great interest. I am still trying to learn to play a smooth and continuous rasgueado and having trimmed my nails this evening, I do notice a difference in attack, tone etc. Playing scales by picado seems much easier with short nails.

On Juan Martin's 42 solos book and dvd, I think he has a longish right hand thumb nail, though I am not sure how he employs it - whether in the upstrokes of the pulgar or in his alzapua's.

many thanks again all, for the responses.
davidj

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 24 2004 22:32:56
 
rickm

 

Posts: 446
Joined: Jan. 23 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

my two sense, most classical and flamenco's I know have fairly long nails. You might try Scott Tennants book, PUmping NYlon, he advocates nails in line with the flesh, and the taper of the nail when you file is critical to how it attacks the strings. ALso, never cut your nails, always file, and what I've been taugtht is to file first and finish with a very fine sandpaper. I coating of vaseline along the bottom of the nail might help your attack as well, but keep it thin or it will obviously muck up your strings. If you have weak nails, as did I, a very good multivitamin a day, plus a fish oil supplement will work wonders and yes you might have to double up the dose for a while. All of these approaches have to be consistent to be effective., good luck.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 26 2004 18:40:42
 
Jamey

Posts: 187
Joined: Jul. 7 2004
From: Winnipeg, Canada

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Well, obviously you'll get as many different opinions as there are guitarists.....

Although it is true that you should try a few different approaches to determine what does and doesn't work for you, here's a few things that I do:

First nutrition:
- multivitamin daily plus about 2000mg of Calcium (brand is not important but if you go this route use one without too much filler junk, I use Jamison). The calcium thing is for thickening the nails and will take at least a couple months of daily intake before you'll see any results (but they DO benefit).

Nail length and shape:
everbody is different in preference, I keep mine a couple of mm at most with the exception of my thumb and small finger. Both are like garden shovels ;-)
You will want to experiment with shape. Eventually you will find that you will want to shape some nails differently than others, depending upon finger and your finger shape (eg: my index finger is a little twisted inward from the middle knuckle to tip due to a poorly healed broken knuckle many moons ago so I have to shape it a little differently to compensate). The shape has a lot to do with the curve of your nails. If you have relatively flat nails (that is, flat across the surface and extending from the finger) then you will probably want to file the tips fairly straight across. If you have very curved nails across the surface, then with a file you'll want to round the corners in so that they don't "hook" the strings. Beyond that, shape is a personal preference thing and you should try different things to get a sense of what works for you.

Nail coating:
I use either OPI Nail Envy (matte finish) or Orly Nail Armour. Typically 3 light coats of either (allow COMPLETE drying in between coats). Both product work reasonably well, with the Orly product drying a little harder than the OPI product but not lasting as long. Both products don't dry your nails out. With the OPI product, I add another light coat every second day and after about a week or so, I strip it off with NON-ACETONE based remover, let dry and start over. You will hear people say they use super glue and swear by it. Super Glue will make your nails very dry, very brittle and thin. You will get caught in cycle of needing to repair your broken nails with the glue as a result of them breaking because the glue weakened them. Avoid this. It will take a very long time for your nails to come back after they've been damaged by glues if you do. I know this because I did it when I started out and would have defended the use of glue until the end. Then I didn't play for 6 months due to a wrist injury and my nails recovered (and then some!).

Note: if you are going to coat your nails with either of the two products I mentioned, be sure to coat the underside of the nail on your thumb and small finger if you decide to grow them longer. Try to avoid the cheap nail hardeners and "teflon tough" type of "strengtheners" as they too will dry out and weaken your nails. The Orly and OPI products cost a little more and are often only found in salons (depending on where you live).

Exposure:
Try not to get strong detergents and any solvents on your nails if they are not protected. Even if they are, try to avoid it (petrol/gas, mineral spirits, acetones, varsols, etc.). If you're washing dishes, wear gloves - they're not great for your nails but far better than not wearing them.

Strings:
I started out playing low tensions and now use hard tension strings. I've noticed no difference in the amount of wear and tear on my nails. It's the nickel winding around the bass strings that causes the wear on your nails. It's the same regardless of string tension since your nails still scrape across them during rasgueados. Tension is a matter of preference.

Though I haven't tried it, I've heard from several sources that turtle shell conditioners from pet stores can actually work wonders. I don't know, it's only second hand info so perhaps try it out for yourself.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 27 2004 4:05:45
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to rickm

many thanks for your advice. Much appreciated. Nice to hear your thoughts on the subject.

best wishes
davidj

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 27 2004 20:24:34
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to Jamey

Jamey,
Many thanks for all your advice and thoughts, which I will weigh up carefully.

I've only recently taken up flamenco, and the more I learn about it, the more daunting it seems to learn the techniques, the timing, the compas, and the palos. -still I've decided to start just for the love of the music. I love the expressiveness of the flamenco guitar, the spirit of it....

I'm going to see Juan Martin in concert on 7 October, .... I've been counting the days until it arrives!

I might see if I can order one of the introductory books by Graf, as I hear his teaching on picado is very good, with a contemporary feel. However, I like the old and the neuvo, so would like to learn both.

davidj

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 27 2004 20:42:05
 
hamia

 

Posts: 403
Joined: Jun. 25 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

I might be responsible for creating the impression that Graf's book is good for teaching picado. Wouldn't buy it just for that reason - he only devotes half a page or so to describing the technique and leaves many questions unanswered. And you can find descriptions of it on the internet in various places.
However, I am a relative newcomer to flamenco and hadn't heard of this method before so was very surprised when I first read about it in his book.

Graf's books are good for learning rasguardo and compass - lots of examples and variations.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 4:55:54
 
Jon Boyes

Posts: 1377
Joined: Jul. 10 2003
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

quote:

ORIGINAL: davidj
I've only recently taken up flamenco, and the more I learn about it, the more daunting it seems to learn the techniques, the timing, the compas, and the palos. -still I've decided to start just for the love of the music. I love the expressiveness of the flamenco guitar, the spirit of it....


Go for it David, and don't be put off by the complexity. Although there are dozens of different styles, there are a limited number of really important ones (how many? which styles are the most common? that would make an interesting thread..)

There are also really a limited number of techniques:

rasgueado
pulgar (inc. alzapua)
picado
arpegio (inc. tremolo)

Ok, there may be countless variations in rasgueado, but you come to a point where you basically have a 'toolkit' of ones that you use, depending on the sound you want to create, and the compas.

I think the great thing about flamenco is that you can delve as deeply as you want, its a folk art after all.

quote:


I might see if I can order one of the introductory books by Graf, as I hear his teaching on picado is very good, with a contemporary feel.


Without going into too much depth, he emphasises the movement of the middle joint in picado, which is probably a more contemporary approach than the straight finger style with the movement coming from the large knuckle. However, they both achieve the same thing for the individual so the sound will be the same.

Some players can get amazing speed this way - Paco being the obvious example - but equally there are players who can't get it to work as well as the older style. You have to try both really, and give both time, to see which is really going to work for you.

Jon
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 8:39:25
 
Escribano

Posts: 6415
Joined: Jul. 6 2003
From: England, living in Italy

What is the least you need? (in reply to Jon Boyes

quote:

There are also really a limited number of techniques:
rasgueado
pulgar (inc. alzapua)
picado
arpegio (inc. tremolo)


The more fiestas I go to, the more I listen, the more I appreciate the importance of the pulgar and rasguedo in compas.

If that was all I learnt and learnt it well, I would be happy to play anyone under the table. In addition, I could do it with just a thumb and index finger (if I had to lose some fingers ).

_____________________________

Foro Flamenco founder and Admin
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 15:35:50
 
Jamey

Posts: 187
Joined: Jul. 7 2004
From: Winnipeg, Canada

RE: fingernails (in reply to Jon Boyes

quote:

Without going into too much depth, he emphasises the movement of the middle joint in picado, which is probably a more contemporary approach than the straight finger style with the movement coming from the large knuckle. However, they both achieve the same thing for the individual so the sound will be the same.


Well I don't have the Graf book and have never actually seen it so I can't even pretend to comment on it's merits.

I haven't had a teacher (ever) so all I know comes from simply trying as many different approaches as I can discover and then sticking to the ones that seem to work best.

Eg: Picado: I keep my fingers "curved" in that they bend at the middle knuckle. However, the movement comes from the main knuckle at the hand and I concentrate on pushing into the sound board rather than across the string. I still manage to play rest strokes this way. It seems more comfortable, I can get a stronger attack, more clarity and a lot more speed (not that speed in picado is the primary goal - it isn't).

Eg 2: Rasgueados: well, there's so many.....I don't think there really is a right and wrong way to do any of them...triplets, four strokes, five strokes - each with a large number of variations. I use about 8 or 9 different ones in various combinations depending upon what I'm doing (or what sounds better to me). I hope this is what everybody else does (dreading that fateful day when I do finally take up with a teacher - perhaps when my son is out of diapers and I have a little more time - yeah right).

I over use my thumb during some rasgueados because rather than the standard triplet of P-A-I that starts with an upstroke with the thumb, I cheat and play it as a four stroke by playing P-A-I-P with the last stroke as a down stroke with the thumb. I just wasn't able to clean up the normal triplet to get it to sound continuous yet I'm able to when I "cheat" with my hack workaround . There is of course an obvious rhythmic pulse to this way of doing it but I've grown to like the effect. Sometimes I substitute my small finger for the anular to get it more distict but only if it's a little slower. I still work on P-A-I but I don't have it working nearly as well (unfortunately).

Anyway David, flamenco is not easy by any stretch but that shouldn't deter you. Just have fun with it. If you're goind to see Juan Martín play, pick up his Solos Flamencos - 42 solos that comes with a dvd and cd. That should help you get started without overwhelming or discouraging you.
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 16:43:42
 
Ron.M

Posts: 7051
Joined: Jul. 7 2003
From: Scotland

RE: What is the least you need? (in reply to Escribano

quote:

In addition, I could do it with just a thumb and index finger

Very true IMO Simon.
With Thumb, Index finger and a couple of good rasgueados, you could accompany most anything out there. (Provided you have the background and knowledge!)
That IMO, is not how Flamenco has been interpreted in the countries outside Spain.
Guitarists have homed in on the "flashy" bits (quite rightly) and taken a decision to try to learn a bit more about this music.
So technique has become a big issue here.
Whereas compás has always been the only issue in Flamenco.

Remember how it used to feel standing up with the band after having 'ad a few and being able to just jam with the rhythm?

Nobody was really worried about more technique than they were capable of.
Main thing was getting the feeling down.
And when somebody extended themselves and did maybe a great over the top solo, then everybody nodded their heads in approval.

Nowaday's folk always talk about tabs and technique in Flamenco.

I'm an Electronics Engineer, but I bet if I had to spend a month intensive training with a Surgeon on only one specialized thing,..say, like taking out an appendix.
I bet I could could do it after that time.
Why not? They do similar sorts of things on "reality" TV.
But would that make me a Surgeon?

Emilio Maya, has after a lifetime's study in Andalucia and at 42 years of age has released his first album.
Yet some "foreign" Flamenco aficionados are planning their first album after a couple of years of taking it up!

Being intellectually and technically proficient enough, and having all the modern "slow down" facilities to be able to work out all the notes and duplicate them, does not, unfortunately turn you into a Flamenco guitarist.

Being able to play a great Bulerias, does not necessarily mean that you can play "por Bulerias".
It just means you can play a worked out Bulerias.
That's all.

So where does this leave us, before we all slit our wrists in despair?

Well, compás has always been the force in Flamenco.

Anyone thinking that this is something that can be learned in ten minutes a day, whereas technique will take a lifetime, is mistaken IMO.

All of our heros started off playing chords, thumb and index, with a couple of rasgueados.
Main thing is they always played Flamenco music. (That is with a feeling for the compás).
And for some of them, their ability and time devoted to the guitar took them to greater heights than those before.

I think the idea of somehow "short circuiting" or "fast tracking" this and somehow becoming a great Flamenco player by listening to solo albums of the greats and practising fast picado every available hour is a myth IMO.

Just makes you good at fast picado. LOL!

cheers

Ron
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 21:17:39
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to hamia

Hamia,
many thanks for the advice. It sounds like a tutorial I should invest in. At the moment, I am working through a number of books, to learn, so I may get Graf Martinuez book later. All the best with your playing.

davidj

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 21:58:26
 
gerundino63

Posts: 1743
Joined: Jul. 11 2003
From: The Netherlands

RE: What is the least you need? (in reply to Ron.M

Hi Ron!

You are quite right about that Ron, but there is no compas without the technique.

How would you do a tremolo or a 5 rasqueado ( xamii) exactly in compas, without the proper technique?

Peter.

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 22:23:35
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to Jon Boyes

Jon,
Many thanks for your sound advice and encouragement yet again.
To my shame, I hadn't listened to much flamenco until recently, and now I find a whole new world of great music, with an expressiveness that somehow has a natural appeal to me. I am conscious of something that Juan Martin has said about the music, that "there are many flashy players with no soul", lots of technique...well maybe there's hope for me yet! I have also discovered that there are some very poor examples of flamenco and I bought a couple of cd's which were big disappointments.

I have heard that the player, Emilio is very good. Do you know of a good cd of his recordings please?

davidj

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 22:34:22
 
davidj

 

Posts: 46
Joined: Aug. 16 2004
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to Jamey

Jon,
yes, I have been working my way through Juan Martin's 42 solos book and dvd and am finding it very helpful. I really appreciate the clips of Spain too. I still have to get myself a flamenco guitar, and thought of visiting Spain to get one, perhaps with the advice of Anders (at someone's suggestion)

davidj

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 28 2004 22:41:29
 
Escribano

Posts: 6415
Joined: Jul. 6 2003
From: England, living in Italy

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

quote:

have heard that the player, Emilio is very good


If you mean Emilio Maya, try clicking on the ad at the top of this page.

_____________________________

Foro Flamenco founder and Admin
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 9:03:59
 
Jon Boyes

Posts: 1377
Joined: Jul. 10 2003
 

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

quote:

ORIGINAL: davidj
I am conscious of something that Juan Martin has said about the music, that "there are many flashy players with no soul", lots of technique...well maybe there's hope for me yet!


IMO there is a lot of wisdom in Rons post above. I'd be the first to put my hand up and say I like the contemporary flashy players, but once you see and hear the relative simplicity of the guitarist's role in context (ie accompanying) it puts a different perspective on it all.


Jon
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 10:28:31
Guest

RE: What is the least you need? (in reply to Ron.M

Hola

What you need in Andalucia and what you need elsewhere are 2 different things. Every weekend I play in a little Peña in the barrio de Santa Maria for two friends. One is a great cantaor, Jose Millan, who knows more cante than anyone in Cadiz. The other is a student of his.

To accopmany Jose, you need very basic flamenco technique, mucho compas and knowledge of the cante. Flashy picado, alzapua or tremolo are irrelevant. Not even falsetas are necessary: they are optional extras.

Any guitarist who opens his case in Andalucia will have to accompany the cante or be written off. This is called flamenco:-).

Sean
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 13:30:27
 
gerundino63

Posts: 1743
Joined: Jul. 11 2003
From: The Netherlands

RE: What is the least you need? (in reply to Guest

Hi Sean.

Do you think the guitar ever gets separated from the cante?

( Like the accordeon from the musette, and the bandoleon from the tango?)

Peter

_____________________________

  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 14:01:25
Guest

RE: What is the least you need? (in reply to gerundino63

Peter
In my opinion, when the guitar is separated from the cante it is no longer flamenco. Only a truly extraordinary guitarist can play flamenco on his own. Obviously this is my personal opinion, but solo guitar in Andalucia is notable for its absence.

Sean
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 15:13:08
 
Escribano

Posts: 6415
Joined: Jul. 6 2003
From: England, living in Italy

RE: What is the least you need? (in reply to Guest

quote:

Any guitarist who opens his case in Andalucia will have to accompany the cante or be written off.


Yeah, that's what I saw in Jerez. No-one pays much attention to a solo guitarist, only when it's with cante.

_____________________________

Foro Flamenco founder and Admin
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 16:15:06
 
Miguel de Maria

Posts: 3532
Joined: Oct. 20 2003
From: Phoenix, AZ

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Always nice to hear Ron splash a little cold water in the face of us "foreign aficionados". Just kidding Ron..but of course, he's right. Reality is never pretty! If we guitarists knew the road ahead of us that stretched from here to proficiency, how many of us would ever take it? A healthy dose of self-delusion goes a long way here. I had a couple of interesting gigs this weekend, maybe my two most interesting ever!

On Sunday, the gig was to play at the Phoenician, our premium resort. My friend Gaetano called me, the idea was there was to be 8 flamenco guitarists, all jamming together. We were going to get ahead of time an hour early and put together a repertoire, and we only had to play 30 min or so. Well I got there, if you can imagine a Ritz or a Four Seasons and make it even larger that's what the Phoenician is like. All marble and brass and towering ceilings and servants walking around. I walked into Las Brisas, the meeting place with Mike Cerio, and there was everyone--Gaetano and Monty from Mosaico, Chris Burton and his student Juanito, a guy named Brent and Miguel Rodriguez, Phoenix' resident flamenco virtuoso. A strange feeling to see them all gathered together! Mosaico plays 4 nights a week, Juanito plays for dancers Fridays and Saturdays, Mike Cerio and his group Del Sol play those nights, and Miguel plays free lance all the time. So a very rare get-together.

The last minute news would be that we 8 would play without amplification. Apparently the powers that be decided that surely 8 guitarsits would be able to project over the large outdoor fountains and 200 people yammering. It being out of our hands, we set to rehearsing. We got together Entre Dos Aguas, put together a quick Sevillanas, some originals from Mosaico, at my suggestion we did Moliendo Cafe and Girl from Ipanema (the always popular). In the half an hour or so we had put together enough stuff, although actually I was dismayed at how bad we sounded. Yes, some of us were learning these songs for the first time, but we just didn't sound together. Everyone seemed to have an idea of how to strum por rumba. And I guess I was part of it, as Gaetano told me twice that I was rushing. (The rumba strum, though supposedly easy, is actually not that easy to do well. There is a swing to it that has to come out, when you do it right you know it. But it's not easy to do).

During the rehearsal I quickly realized that my status among the flamencos of Phoenix hadn't changed much. Gaetano's strums were so rich and strong, so full of energy, and he had picado runs and other flash tricks that he executed with incredible projection and verve. I was amazed at how loud Monty could play, his leads coming out clearly over 7 guitarists strumming. Chris played well, and his student Juanito ripped out Vicente Amigo lick after another, effortlessly and cleanly. And Miguel was his normal self, dropping jaws even among this group with his technical speed and Paco-like picado. I realized quickly that I didn't have the cajones to stand out with these people. My picado is fast but erratic and not loud. I decided that I would play the role of strummer, clapper, and entertainer, but not guitar whiz. There were enough here already.

We walked to the outside fountain where 8 chairs were set up. I felt like a rock group or the Gipsy Kings as we strode, guitars in hand, and past wondering people, to our spot. We played our first song, and it was a strange thing. As I sat next to Gaetano, I could hear him. To my right was Mike Cerio, and I could hear him--a little. The guitarists to the left or right of them, I could hear faintly, very faintly, and nothing beyond that. So of the eight, only 3 of them really factored into my realm. This is the problem with not having monitoring. We couldn't hear eacah other. And if we couldn't hear each other, how could we play together? It's like having a conversation with someone you can't hear. Impossible!

Now we had a lot of strummers, so I realized that I could just strum my muted guitar to make a percussion sound. Also I could clap. I did these percussion things more than strum, actually. And Gaetano sang some, not an easy feat considering we were outside and he had to project, and I sang harmonies where I could. I was pleased to realize I could sing upper harmonies to his voice, my opera training coming in handy!

The entertainment agent came around and told us that plans had changed, and asked us if could actually play for 2 hours instead of half an hour. We would get paid more, of course. Without too much discussion, we agreed. The agent said, "You guys are truly wallflowers. Don't worry about projecting, and you can repeat material, that's fine. We realize the situation you're in. And when you take your breaks, just do it one or two at a time, but keep the music going."

As we walked to our second set, Monty made the comment that he noticed that I was having trouble doing palmas to the rumbas. So not only can't I do picado, or strum, I couldnt' even manage to clap right. We were in the bathroom and he and Gaetano made me clap with them. It seems that clapping for rumba is a little tricky, because the rumba accent comes right after the clap. So they don't match up. And as you know, if syncopation is not done precisely it sounds horrible. We spent about five minutes pracitcing palmas and getting me to do the contras, which was fun. I learned that it is easier to do contras with palmas sordas than the claritas for some reason.

The second set was pretty bad. We could not hear each other at all. A musician can only take so much of this, no matter how mcuh he is getting paid, and people began to lose their energy. I could tell. Postures slumped. Attitudes soured. Monty and I decided to do palmas but it didn't work, because the strums to the left of us and the right of us declined to follow our rhythm. I can't even imagine how it sounded to anyone who could hear us. But no one could hear us past 15 feet and that's where the people were!

Anyways, the gig ended with a whimper. Rather tired from strumming all night with no amplification, and drained from the experience of playing bad music, we put up our gear and split up. Before we left, I took the opportunity to get a mini-lesson with virtuoso Miguel Rodriguez. I told him, "I can play fast picado, but it's not consistent, and I can only do it after I warm up the lick for 15 minutes or so." We played throuh Panaderos Flamencos at a moderate tempo. He said, "Do you start your runs with the i finger?" I said that I almost always did. He advised me to begin practicing all of them with the m finger from now on, and that would solve the problem. Ah, the fix of wisdom from above!

The second weird gig was to play at a wedding reception. The bride was a nice and excitable Polish lady whose accent I found impenetrable. Eventually, on the very day of the wedding, I found out for sure that I was to start at 545 and play for 2 hours. Okay! I got to the country club, one of our nicer ones in Phoenix. The DJ was there, he was Polish, and said that I could use his equipment, so that was nice I wouldn't have to set up anything.

When the bridal party arrived, it was in an enormous 50 ft long stretch HumVee. You may have seen HumVees in the Persian Gulf war, they are the US' modern version of the jeep. Wel now they make limouisines out of them, but they are the length of busses. Out of the giant HumVee stepped a gorgeous lady in a wedding dress and her gorgeous attendents. So they were quite rich, it seemed. I had a momentary wish that I had charged them more for my appearance, a rather mean feeling of course, and completely moot since I charge all clients, rich or poor the same.

Since this was a Polish wedding reception, it was somewhat more complex than what I was used to. First they were announced by the DJ and they came into applause. After that there was a receiving line. Then there was an assortment of Polish songs, mostly involving drinking. The manager of the restaurant said that the bride had flown 30 of her family in from Poland. "She spent some money on this wedding," she remarked. I looked around at the people and tried to size them up. They looked like quite normal people to me. The bride looked very spectacular, though, and rich with her long diamond-studded earrings. As a musician who caters to the "leisure class," I try to learn what rich people look like, how they act, and how they expect their musicians to act, in order to market more successfully to them. And let me tell you--the rich are different (see Rob's post on castle trash).

At long last, it was my turn to play. I was announced by the DJ "sometihing in Polish....Miguel de Maria!" Everyone clapped, and I sat down at my spot which was right in the middle of the dance floor. I noticed that everyone was watching me expectantly and began to grow a little nervous. I am not an exhibitionistic person by nature...am more of a guitar tinkerer than performer. But over the last year (starting in February), I have done enough solo gigs to realize that for the first song, people usually listen, before they grow bored and start to talk racously amongst themselves. So I began with Soleareas, a calm piece that I could probably play in the dark and buffeted by a hurricane. As I played, I noticed something both edifying and quite scary--they were listening. That's fine, that's fine, I thought, they'll lose interest and go back to doing whatever they do and I'll be able to play in peace. I finished the Soleares and everyone applauded. I looked up and made eye contact and nodded and smiled to them.

Now my mind was racing. This was an unusual situation--I was playing and people were listening--all of them! Now this may seem like a weird thought for me to have,but as Jon will tell you, no one listens to musicians at gigs. We are just there for status, for the special added energy a live musician brings, but we aren't really there to be watched. We are background music for well-to-do people. But background nonetheless. I began my second piece, a rumba, and my mind was racing. They were still watching. They were eating, but they were listening. I could tell because they were so quiet. They were the most quiet eaters I had ever seen. My problem was, some of my pieces I play very well and with confidence, others are so so and others are not. I play the bad pieces in lulls or when no in is listening. When is say bad it is usually because they are very complex and I don't have them mastered 100%. There is no way I could pull them off if everyone were watching! So how the heck was I going ot play for 2 hours!

Song after song went by, still with the same disturbing pattern of quiet, finale, applause. This was not background music, this was indeed a concert. How fortunate that I got this gig now, after I have had almost a year of experience playing solo. If it had been only 6 months earlier, I would have crashed and burned horribly. The groom came up to me, and said, "That Ottmar Liebert song on your demo CD, Barcelona nights, could you play that?" I said, "Well Barcelona nights isn't on my demo, but this one is--" I played a little bit of Road 2 U (one of my "B" songs), that one? No, he shook his head. I stuttered, "well, well, I kind of need 2 guitars to do that one..." He smiled at me, "No one will notice, just do your best!" I smiled, "Of course." And launched into Road 2 U. Now the song he wanted Barcelona Nights has a strong and irritating melody over strummed guitars. How could I possibly play that with only one guitar? I really had no idea.

Next I played Pachelbel's Canon--something to calm me down. When I finished a man of about 90 calledme over. He said, "You play really well young man. That piece you just played--the Gymnopedie, was exellent, excellent!" I started to tell him that it was by Johan Pachelbel, not Edward Satie, but realized there was no point. His enjoyment was genuine, why correct him? I limped back to my chair (as my leg had fallen asleep), suddenly very conscious of howI looked. Everyone was watching me after all, this was a concert! I sat down and began to rumba strum with muted strings. Thwak a thwak THWAK a thwak a! And played the annoying and strident melody of Barcelona nights...several times. Immediately a cry of surprise and joy rose from the crowd. They loved it! They perked up and heads whipped around. I was playing BARCELONA NIGHTS! But how was I to play it, I was only one guitar!

My solution, made up on the spot was to just go to the 2nd part and strum the chords. So no melody, just strumming. I ended it with a huge Marote rasgeaudo.... BA DA DA DA DA DA DA DA DA! And then the melody, but wait, there is no 2nd guitar, how is this going to work? Inspiration struck and I stomped very hard on the downbeats on the dance floor as I played the melody. People began clapping as the annoying melody calledout. Hey it sounded okay, I guess! Back to bridge, big rasgeaudo BA DA DA DA D AD AD D A! The melody one more time, a rasgeaudo, and done!

Standing ovation! People went crazy!

I smiled and thanked them for their applause, but inside I was in a state of disbelief. I had never known this song was so popular and in fact it's my least favorite of all songs I ever play. When things died down, I went back to work. It was pretty quiet, except when I played El Condor Pasa, which received a somehwat similiar response to the Barcelona Nights. Finally the bride said, that as we were running late and needed to keep to the schedule, I only needed to play one more song. I did a Sevillanas and a couple toddlers spontaneously jumped on stage and tried to dance. Finally it was over!

When I tried to pack my guitar away I discovered that the case had locked itself somehow. So I left the scene of the concert with my case and bag in one hadn and guitar in the other. They paid me the remainder of my fee with a $100 tip! Always nice! Somehow I had survived the gig!
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 17:00:25
 
Patrick

Posts: 1189
Joined: Jul. 7 2003
From: Portland, Oregon

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Miguel,

Great story!

I often envy you guys that play for a living, but then I bang my head against a wall and come back to my senses!

Pat
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 18:24:01
 
Ron.M

Posts: 7051
Joined: Jul. 7 2003
From: Scotland

RE: fingernails (in reply to Miguel de Maria

quote:

Always nice to hear Ron splash a little cold water in the face of us "foreign aficionados".


Mike,
Don't ever think that the comment was ever directed at you (or Jon for that matter of fact).
You guys have never marketed yourselves as "Virtuoso Flamenco Guitarists", like others have.
You are both good working guitarists in the Entertainment Industry.
People enjoy your stuff and you get paid for it.
So all the best with your respective CD's.
I respect both of you immensely.
Hey, Paco might be a God to those in the know, but he's a member of the Entertaiment Industry too!
With only an aficionado audience, then all these heros would die of starvation!
In fact, this is how bad it gets....
I let an aquaintance hear a bit of Paco de Lucia.
He said "Yea...I love that Spanish stuff on the guitar....have you ever heard of "Manitos de Platos"...he's the best in the World you know...plays same kind of stuff as your Santa Luchia guy........"

"God", I thought ...."I'll let Paco know.....I'm sure he'll be flattered"

LOL!

Ron
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 20:01:09
 
Miguel de Maria

Posts: 3532
Joined: Oct. 20 2003
From: Phoenix, AZ

RE: fingernails (in reply to davidj

Of course, not Ron, I think you and I are in accord on this subject. My new thing is marketing myself as a "Spanish and Southwestern Guitarist", I think that label will get me more gigs!
  REPORT THIS POST AS INAPPROPRIATE |  Date Sep. 29 2004 20:08:18
Page:   [1] 2    >   >>
All Forums >>Discussions >>General >> Page: [1] 2    >   >>
Jump to:

New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts


Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET

0.109375 secs.