Florian -> RE: CHALLENGE SUGGETIONS (Jan. 26 2009 3:29:59)
|
greate its good to see that u guys are ok with the challenge so far....the quicker we can get this logistics out of the way the faster we can move on to the fun parts.. I am sorry if i seem a litlle pushy lol I hope I dont seem too dismisive of others ideas. without atleast fair explonation...its from good intentions...u guys know what happens everytime we discuss this things too much lol..we kill the momentum the most important thing is that we do it...if anyone has any suggestions thats cool but make sure its worded out exactly and clear to understand, detailed, doable and simple....if someone has a greate idea, brilliant i am more then happy to follow it but please be specific and think detail..... i was reminded today that the workshop with the woman from spain is starting next week, so myself have to stay on guajira and cantinas ( was starting to get bored of guajiras lol) but i am more then happy to help get organised, provide whatever u need and vote if you want it.. Deniz your idea is good but personally i dont think participants should judge atleast not in the same class they compete in..its a conflict of interest...its not that i dont trust your fairness is just not really done...it could become about oh....he was kind to me so il be generous with him..or the oposite etc.. or imagine this theres only 7 point difference between you winning and Joe wining...everyone has cast theyr votes...and u are leading by 7 points..the only vote left to be casted is yours....will you not be tempted to give Joe a 6 ? lol ...I am human i might [:D][:D] i just dont wanna put you guys in that situation...plus we should keep it as simple as possible.. we either make it everyone who dosent compete votes or about 8, 10, 15 whatever amount of judges you guys wish to nominate.. its just too complicated other ways isnt it ? and someone suggested a great way to vote..I was thinking about it and it makes sence..to me.if you wanna vote the guy u are voting on deserves to atleast see you do it to his face..just to avoid any **** or anyone using this as an excuse to bash someone... however keep in mind that judges will be judges, they will not be doing anyone any favours this time, they will vote according to them....its important that each person that judges is as honest as posible to theyr opinion instead of anonymus...each person voting will mark from 1 to 10 with 10 beeing the highest for 3 or 4 criterias we agree on..example. Deniz technique 10 compas 9 aire 10 total 29 there is a possibility there might be 2 winners ...nothing wrong with that..or we can think of making the criteria more detiled to reduce the chances of a draw...eg. mark techniques individualy rasqueado 7 arpegio 9 picado 10 rithm 10 timing 10 aire 10 total 56 its harder to get identical overall scores so what do you think ? Can we start voting on the judging ? either nominate as many members as you like to vote ( and use names)...or we all agree that everyone that dosent participate can vote...its up to those of you who are taking part in the challenge.. depending who wants to take part in the challenge or voting I nominate people like Ron, Todkk, Grisha, Ricardo, JasonM, Sean, Pimientito, Norman K, John O, Doit, Kate, Anders etc......i cant take it cause I have to practice diferent things so id like to vote if you will have me..whomever wants to vote or take the challenge should speak up..u cant do both...so Todkk, you might have to just pick one...but whomever wants to take the challenge by all means take it...dont setlle for judging...i am defenetly in the next one... whomever votes you want a broad selection that covers many different opinions and tastes, i nominated judges who see it from different angles too...wich will make it interesting and wide open..
|
|
|
|