Welcome to one of the most active flamenco sites on the Internet. Guests can read most posts but if you want to participate click here to register.
This site is dedicated to the memory of Paco de Lucía, Ron Mitchell, Guy Williams, Linda Elvira, Philip John Lee, Craig Eros, Ben Woods, David Serva and Tom Blackshear who went ahead of us.
We receive 12,200 visitors a month from 200 countries and 1.7 million page impressions a year. To advertise on this site please contact us.
Firstly, let me apologise for repeatedly raising these boring old cultural questons...
But I was watching a programme on BBC4 recently about Django Reinhardt. It was a documentary, but quite sharply done and very revealing.
One thing that struck me was the attitudes of the people featured. Many claimed to be big DR fans, but knew little or nothing about the man himself and his background. Some were "obsessive" types and seemed to have an unbalanced passion for the man and his music... influencing virtually every part of their lifestyle.
Others seemed to have an appreciation for his music, but appeared to care little for the man himself and his culture. A good quote was from a Japanese enthusiast, who agreed that "there was a place in Japan for Gypsy Jazz, but NOT for gypsies!"
In fact many of the locals near where Django used to live were quite un-complimentary about gypsies in general.
DR was a gypsy, and some of the people interviewed were gypsies too. Some of them seemed enthusiastic about DR really just because of what he represented, rather than because of his music. A few didn't seem to know much about him at all.
Although obviously very talented, issues were raised about DR's character. And he was rumoured to have been unpleasant at times. It is also believed that he performed for the Nazi party whilst many of his gypsy colleagues were being persecuted by them.
I found the whole programme fairly interesting. Some people trying to get as close to the spirit of DR as possible, others doing the same, but in completely different ways. Many interpreting the man and his music to suit their own needs.
It all brought me back to a recent discussion on the foro where some members were debating guitar skills versus personality... which is better and can the two be combined well. Its struck me that very few people actually knew what the spirit of DR was, and so their attempts to get close to it may have been unsuccessful.
Perhaps those in the documentary that seemed to get closest to capturing the spirit of Django were those who focused mainly on his music.
But I'm not sure if its really important to get close to the spirit of a musician, as long as "the music" is enjoyed... is it?
Translating this into Flamenco terms, I was wondering what it actually means to be a gitano (or gypsy) and if this is really relevant to understanding Flamenco as a whole. Or perhaps it doesn't matter whether you understand a musician's personality and culture, and music appreciation is all that is required?
BTW... are the gypsies associated with Django of the same lineage of those associated with Flamenco?
Sorry... that really was a bit long and boring, wasn't it?!
Posts: 15242
Joined: Dec. 14 2004
From: Washington DC
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
I have had a lot of dealings with gypsies, mainly spanish and romanian, and am friends with several. In my experience, it really depends how deeply involved in the clan or old fashioned they are, that affects they way they act or play music. For flamenco, there is gypsy flamenco and non gypsy flamenco, just like you have american jazz and "gypsy jazz". Same with spanish rumba vs french gypsy rumba. These are ways to stereo type the music and the people who play it, but there is a reason to make distinctions. That does not mean you won't have gypsies in that culture that DON"T play or sing or whatever, in the typical way all their cousins do. Likewise you will find non gypsies that really undertand how to play like a gypsy, and some in fact make the culture there own. I know both kinds and could give examples. But my point is, there IS a distinction to be made, understood by those involved (actual players, not the hippies). You don't have to be a gypsy to play flamenco, or even play "gypsy flamenco", but if you can play, you will start to understand the subtlties of the distinction.
And just because you are gypsy, does not give you a gold key to get "into" whatever gypsy music style you want. Gitanos from spain don't care about Django necessarily, nor do Romanian Gypsies care anything about cante jondo. In fact you have closed off separate clans right in side a certain musical style, that don't get along. I can't tell how many times I have heard gypsy friends tell me "you see those gypsies over there, they are the bad ones, stay away". There are predjudices everywhere, and I have seen first hand how they get born. There were 3 clans of romanian gypsies that used to come to one of my restaurant gigs and take over the place when we played. They eventually got BAND/prohibited literally from coming into the place, HERE in the USA! One gypsy friend told me "good!, you don't want that clan where you play", knowing HE too was prohibited. No one knows better what kind of problems arise when a group of gypsies get together, than the gypsies themselves, LOL!
Posts: 1827
Joined: Jul. 8 2003
From: Living in Granada, Andalucía
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
quote:
ORIGINAL: JBASHORUN BTW... are the gypsies associated with Django of the same lineage of those associated with Flamenco?
Django was Manouche from France and the Gypsies of Andalucia are Cale. Different tribes altogether but possibly the same lineage going way back. Richard sums up very well how it is in Gypsy communities and between clans. Many differences. There is great controversy about the recent name " Roma" to cover all of the tribes.
While there is prejudice amongst them the prejudice against Gypsies is still worse. A friend told me how at the Juan Carmona concert in Chicago the other night she sat next to a couple who told her that their daughter was going to Sevilla to study flamenco dance, then added " She knows better than to get involved with the Gypsies though" My friend asked why and was told that many Gypsies had a problem with drugs and alcahol, to which she replied "So do many Americans".
I found it interesting that this friend , although a lover of flamenco, had not realised it had anything to do with Gypsies. She thought it was the Spanish National dance.
Posts: 1945
Joined: Jul. 12 2004
From: San Francisco
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Kate)
That's pretty funny Kate, about the girl who wanted to study flamenco in spain, but not "get involved with gypsies" I've been doing business with many gypsy families for more than twenty years and think they are probably the most unique culture in the U.S. I really think anyone who wants to get into flamenco should probably make an effort to understand the Spanish gypsy culture as a way of gaining some insight into the music, and where it came from. I think that some of the ways the music is put together, like the parallel modulation, certain accidentals, are consistant with a mindset that I have observed in many gypsies. The expressiveness and the tragedy in the music has been obvious in the personalities of the gypsy families that I know, although these gypsies have no connection to flamenco. My wife is a native spanish speaker and has a nice singing voice. I suggested years ago maybe she should try to learn some cante. She said she was way to happy to sing like that.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
Theres a video documentary about Gypsys in europe. and their diffrent cultures. they let you follow them from India where they first are belived to have come from and the all the way to france, spain, finlad etc.
almost all styles of music you see share similar things in expression and rythm but not flamenco. I think i´t because the spanish gypsys were they only ones to have been in contact with arabe culture. The flamenco gypsy music are so very diffrent from the other gypsys music.
can´t remember the name of the video.
Henrik
_____________________________
This is hard stuff! Don't give up... And don't make it a race. Enjoy the ray of sunshine that comes with every new step in knowledge.
Posts: 1827
Joined: Jul. 8 2003
From: Living in Granada, Andalucía
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Mark2)
quote:
ORIGINAL: Mark2 My wife is a native spanish speaker and has a nice singing voice. I suggested years ago maybe she should try to learn some cante. She said she was way to happy to sing like that.
There's happy cante, like alegrías, bulerías, tangos. Its not all cante jondo.
There was a film/documentary made recently about Gypsies in the USA called "The Hidden American" ( I think). Apparently there are more than 2,000,000 in the USA but have no idea where I got that figure from so dont quote me, probably remembered from the publicity from the film.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
Here's a domino effect. Many people think gypsies are untrustworthy, therefore, it is harder for them to find a place in society, and to find work. This prejudice eventually results in "untrustworthy" behaviour from the opressed minority, whose actions result from dislillusionment or lack of social support, which then results in a re-affirmation of the idea tha they are all untrustworthy. Etc, etc.
That aside, I do believe music reflects on personality. DR, like Picasso, like many other artists, are particularly free spirited individuals. They felt very little need to chain themselves with responsibility or obligation, and expressed themselves to a degree most of us would never dare. It's not a good thing, it's not a bad thing. It's simply the way they are, and it suffuses their work. It is possible to be drawn to this sort of intensity even if you feel they are ethically questionable.
Paco Pena's sense of a detachment, or a certain lack of synchronicity with the prevailing cultural trend, Juan Martin's apparent sense of nostalgia, Mozart's drive and enthusiaism and Wagner's hollow, vain antipathy can all be delievered in music, in terms often clearer than even actual behaviour.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
quote:
I think i´t because the spanish gypsys were they only ones to have been in contact with arabe culture. The flamenco gypsy music are so very diffrent from the other gypsys music.
You should add, and this before arab music, that the Spanish gypsies got in touch with SPANISH culture and music. The spanish part is still the strongest influence in flamenco (phrygian scale and 12 counts)
Posts: 1827
Joined: Jul. 8 2003
From: Living in Granada, Andalucía
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Miguel de Maria)
quote:
ORIGINAL: Miguel de Maria
2 million!? I wonder where they are hiding, I have only seen one gypsy family my whole time here.
How did you know they were a Gypsy family? Were they in traditional Gypsy dress ? Most American Gypsies will look no different from many other Americans. I know of many Romanies in the USA but they dont go round waving their churries, wearing diklos or dukkering palms.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Kate)
In sweden the gypsys are called "Romer" and their language "Romska"(romani) They wear traditional dresses almost all the time i see any and thats quite a often. well i should say the the WOMEN dress trad. never seen any men in trad dress. only in leather jacket and jeans.
Actually the place in sweden where i live has it´s own dialect that comes from the "traveling folks" that use to sell things at a market place in town. The "travlers" were "Romer" (gyspys)
Henrik
Ps i live in Jönköping, and its almost only old people that knows the dialect.
_____________________________
This is hard stuff! Don't give up... And don't make it a race. Enjoy the ray of sunshine that comes with every new step in knowledge.
Posts: 3532
Joined: Oct. 20 2003
From: Phoenix, AZ
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
Kate, I was in a convenience store and in comes this dusky-colored group of people, who were not Mexican or any other ethnicity I could identify. They looked more Italian to me, I guess. They spoke a language which I could not identify. The woman was pregnant. I asked one of them what that language were, and they looked at me with a somewhat suspicious glare. One of the men answered, and I think he said "Romani" or something like that. He explained they were Gypsies.
Posts: 1945
Joined: Jul. 12 2004
From: San Francisco
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Kate)
American gypsies have an accent that is easy to identify if you are familiar with it. Kate, I know about the happy cantes of course, but that was my non aficianado wife's impression from hearing the music around the house and at shows. You have to admit, even in bulerias , the intensity singers display is enough to color a person's perception
Posts: 15242
Joined: Dec. 14 2004
From: Washington DC
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Kate)
quote:
How did you know they were a Gypsy family? Were they in traditional Gypsy dress ? Most American Gypsies will look no different from many other Americans. I know of many Romanies in the USA but they dont go round waving their churries, wearing diklos or dukkering palms.
I understand your point, but honestly, I personally can tell right away. Like I said, I hang with some of them regularly. There are so many manerisms, even the way they dress in America. Like the bling bling and the bright white tennis shoes or suite. But really, I hang out with lots of ethnic groups, I can tell a gypsy by his face and eyes, just like most typical americans can recognize Asians and Africans. (People from south america can really tell how "Indian" someone is just by their face. That is harder for me. ) I can tell who is probably Persian or Turkish. And amongst a lot of these middle eastern and gypsy groups in America, they have this thing about changing their names and pretending they are part Italian for some reason. But I have learned through friends how to make these distinctions. It is educational to say the least.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
Maybe this with the white tennis shoes etc, may it says more about the types you like to hang around with
Just joking. Ricardo, I´m very sure that I can take you for a walk here in my village and you´ll find it VERY difficult to see who´s gipsy or not. Some (a lot) just don´t fit into these stereotype things. My landlord is gipsy, and I dont think you´d know if you weren´t told.
Posts: 3532
Joined: Oct. 20 2003
From: Phoenix, AZ
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
Is there a point, through interbreeding, where Gypsy becomes more of a cultural group than an ethnicity?
By the way, I know what you mean about how indio someone is. I started to notice that when I hung out with a lot of Mexicans. Some of them are obviously very European looking, even blond/green eyed, while others look like they have little European blood--very "Aztec" looking I think.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Ricardo)
Thanks guys... interesting stuff. I personally do not know any gypsies at all. In fact, the first thing that comes to mind (rightly or wrongly) when I hear the word "gypsy" is the Eastern European type, or possibly the Irish ones. I have never conversed with any, but the Eastern European ones have a reputation for begging on trains over here. They also do a have quite a distinctive dress sense. Well, different from the average Londoner, anyway (if there is such a thing as "an average Londoner").
Kate... "Sinti"? Is that a branch of the gypsy lineage? If so, that would make you part gypsy too...
Posts: 15242
Joined: Dec. 14 2004
From: Washington DC
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Guest)
quote:
Just joking. Ricardo, I´m very sure that I can take you for a walk here in my village and you´ll find it VERY difficult to see who´s gipsy or not. Some (a lot) just don´t fit into these stereotype things. My landlord is gipsy, and I dont think you´d know if you weren´t told.
No doubt when races mix, it is hard to tell by their look. Same goes for identifying African or Asian who are mixed with something else. To complicate the issue, there are lots of non gypsies who hang out with them or do their music or whatever, that claim to be gypsy or part gypsy, but are NOT at all! I have a friend who admits to not having ANY gypsy blood, but is married to a gypsy, grew up with gypsy friends, raises his children with them, and part takes in the culture as if he himself were one, plays the music, dress, etc. Because of all this he feels it it gives him the right to call himself a gypsy. Ask him where he comes from, and he won't tell you all the details of his life, simply that yes he is a gypsy. Even though, it is easy to see by his face and features, he does not have the race in his blood.
He is not unique, I have met many who claim to be gypsy from whatever typical gypsy town, later to find out they are not at all gypsy by blood. So "gypsy" can be more a cultural thing than a race thing at times. I am sure there are gypsies out there that pretend they are "Italian" as well.
The Romanian ones I refered to in America that I know well, they are pure blood with arranged marriages, etc. Very distinct look. I know some Spanish gypsies who are mixed that are harder to tell for sure, but there is this thing with the eyes and eye brows/nose that gives it away if the blood is there.
Posts: 429
Joined: Jan. 7 2005
From: Iasi, Romania
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
I wanted to post several times on this subject ,but there are so ...touchy subjects for me. I had some little troubles with some gipsies here.This is a very complex issue ,but the gipsies here ...were marginalized for some time but I think to tell exactly who's fault is ,is not that simple.Now with all EU programs things started to turn around,and there are beeing made some efforts to integrate the gipsies into society.
But it's not that easy,they are a closed comunity ..and u have the impression that they dont wanna integrate.For example to discover in some vilage a mariage between a girl of 14 years old and a boy ,doesnt seem quite tolerable...cause it's illegal.A lot of romanians put a blame on them cause of the bad publicity we get in the world and it is true ...they do take organized crime rather seriously.I worked in a net cafe ,for some money ..and I got slaped in public by a couple of gipsies from a clan "corduneanu" cause I didnt do smth(the boss said ...u cant do nothing about it,the police is too slow ..for this sht)
...well.long story short...when they get organized,local autorities have great dificulties..if it gets big ,the police solves it ...but small delicts are usually permited cause u cant do nothing about it.
I dont take it on gispy ,I know there are good and bad people wherever...but still this integration process still has a lot to go.For example by law every kid at 7 years of age has to go to school ..their kids usually dont.Now,they are poor ...and some dont go cause they have no means...but u can find all sort of gipsies poor and quite welthy.
The romanians didnt quite like it when the gipsied started to call themself "romani". We were afraid of the bad publicity they take upon them when they usually emigrate. Romanian culture is very different from theirs ...they have their own language and all,and it's not a latin language or smth.We here call them "tigani" and not "romani" though we are quite familiar with the term. Anyway ,it's very hard to explain it all...and I cant it will take more than 10 pages. There are for sure bad and good sides of this story.But it's just too hard to say smth general ,that maybe u should not even try ...U cant imagine how many politicians discused this subject .
I think that flamenco is flamenco cause of the mixing with spanish culture.Sure arabic culture is an important aspect ,but we also have in our gipsy and our romanian music minor armonic scales ,melodic ..and scales with the 2+ interval.Romania fought a lot of battles with the turks ,and was for a long time under the influence of the otoman empire. But we had lot of influences like slavs (i hope that's a word) ,austro-hungarian empire,greeks ..etc. The miracle is that we have a latin language and nowhere near us any other latin country.For example Spain , France ,Italy,Portugal are very close on the map.The latin language we have it from 106 AC when Traian (roman emperor) conquered Dacia (where is now romania).Gee...how the hell , did I end up telling about this. Read it all on wikipedia.
So, in a way in romania ..we had some arabic influences + some gipsies+ latin language= still no flamenco .The thing is that phrigian scale ...I mean I remember when first seeing some flamenco on tv.It was just like Ricardo said ....I kept listening to a guy who played guitar and didnt understand why doesnt he finishes the song ,kept awaiting for him to finish the introductory part ....come on man ,play that Am
Posts: 1827
Joined: Jul. 8 2003
From: Living in Granada, Andalucía
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
quote:
ORIGINAL: JBASHORUN Kate... "Sinti"? Is that a branch of the gypsy lineage? If so, that would make you part gypsy too...
Yep a small part from my Great Great Grandfather. Sinti are from Germany and France though the family always claimed to be Italian. They are closely related to the Cale and certainly there a lot of old Gitanas here who look just like my Grandmother and her mother. My Grandmother was well known in her neighbourhood ( Splott, by the docks in Cardiff) for reading tealeaves and charming away warts.
Posts: 1827
Joined: Jul. 8 2003
From: Living in Granada, Andalucía
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to Ricardo)
A friend of mine was born on the road in the USA and travelled with her Kumpania until she married. With red hair and a Texas accent you wouldn't know she was Lovari, her son is in the marines, is in Iraq right now and likewise with him you wouldn't know. My friend speaks Romanes but her children dont and they dont arrange marriages they are settled and totally integrated.
It sounds like your friends still keep the culture. What tribe are they from ? By the way bling bling is big here with the Cale but not the white tennis shoes.
There's a guy here in Granada who claims to be Gypsy, he dyes his hair black, the reality is he's French.
RE: GITANOS... & DJANGO REINHARDT (in reply to JBASHORUN)
irish travellers (gypsies) tend to have a thing about bling as well, alot of gold necklaces,thick gold rings and saint anthony and saint michael relgious medals. the origins of irish gypsies is still under debate but alot of people tend to agree they were in a large part people swept off their land during the great famine here and continued to roam.
my aunt is married to irish travellers and my cousins are travellers and they're as nice a bunch of people as you'd ever like to meet. funnily enough though in looks and hairstyle the irish travellers looks similiar to gitanos except they are a little less tanned. one guy i met a two year back would be the spitting image of tomatito.
btw the irish travellers are welll know for there music here as basically being on the move the whole time they picked up a large body of music through travelling county to county, and some of the more famous travellers include the furey brothers. they like banjo guitar and tin whistle playing alot and some are very exceptional on the fiddle, and most of the instruments which they played were hand made by themselves or other travellers.