Influence of Lefthandconversion (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - Lutherie: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=22
- - - Influence of Lefthandconversion: http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=58428



Message


ms17a -> Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 3 2007 13:05:23)

Hello everyone,

until now, I've been a "passive" forum member and quiet new to playing flamenco (about 3/4 year). I have also been playing bass for 17 years and due to my exploration of this Instrument (4 string => 5string => 6string fretless), I discovered Flamenco as one of the biggest musical challenges. So, that's where I started from and here's my little problem: I am lefthanded and thus limited in my choice of guitar models.

What effects will a lefthandconversion of a right handed classical/flamenco guitar have? Of course a bridge adjustment is necessary, but what effects will a symmetric/asymmetric bracing of the top have on such a converted guitar. I am not sure but all flamenco guitars I've seen so far have a symmetric bracing an thus a "convertable"...Am I wrong with this opinion?

Greetings,

Mark




Anders Eliasson -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 3 2007 15:24:52)

Hi Mark

The biggest problem is that maybe the saddle will have a slight angle.

This with asymetrical guitars... Well I´ve tried a right hand guitar that was builded left hand and it sounded absolutely ok. I think its a myth that asymetrical guitars play the trebles in one side and bass in the other.... I think they just sound a bit different




Per Hallgren -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 4 2007 14:58:59)

Even if it is more common on classical guitars than on flamencos you need to check the fingerboard for asymmetry so that the bass side isn't thinner towards the soundhole than the treble side. You also need to make a new nut and saddle to convert the guitar to a lefthand. All the rest is as good for left hand playing as for the normal righthand playing. The eventual asymmetries in the soundbox construction works equally for both . There is no treble or bass side loooking only on the acoustical function, in my opinion.

Check that the golpeador is ok for your playing too...




TANúñez -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 4 2007 16:40:53)

quote:

Hello everyone,

until now, I've been a "passive" forum member and quiet new to playing flamenco (about 3/4 year). I have also been playing bass for 17 years and due to my exploration of this Instrument (4 string => 5string => 6string fretless), I discovered Flamenco as one of the biggest musical challenges. So, that's where I started from and here's my little problem: I am lefthanded and thus limited in my choice of guitar models.

What effects will a lefthandconversion of a right handed classical/flamenco guitar have? Of course a bridge adjustment is necessary, but what effects will a symmetric/asymmetric bracing of the top have on such a converted guitar. I am not sure but all flamenco guitars I've seen so far have a symmetric bracing an thus a "convertable"...Am I wrong with this opinion?

Greetings,

Mark


I'm a lefty. I've been converting right handed guitars for as long as I've been playing. As long as the fingerboard is straight or flat(no taper) you can convert it. Makes no difference if the bracing is symmetrical or not.

You will have to make a new nut and saddle. That's about it. It's especially easy if the saddle slot is straight across. If it's compesated(angled) you'll have to have a luthier fill in the slot with matching rosewood and cut out the slot again with a reversed angle.

Most golpeadores(tap plates) will be cut for a right hander. More coverage on the treble side. So, when you reverse the guitar, you'll have more coverage on your bass side. You can cut a little piece of golpeador to use as an extension on your treble side, or, you can just be extra careful not to golpe too far down hitting the unprotected wood.




Anders Eliasson -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 4 2007 16:45:17)

quote:

I'm a lefty. I've been converting right handed guitars for as long as I've been playing


The lovely life of leftys[:D]

Tom How many of the guitars you have build have been lefthanded? all?




TANúñez -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 5 2007 13:25:33)

quote:

The lovely life of leftys

Tom How many of the guitars you have build have been lefthanded? all?


It hasn't been so lovely Anders, lefties have no rights [:(]

They've all been left handed except for my last one. I made it rightly so my former teacher could play and "test" it. He bought it on the spot!. I was not intending to sell it as I felt it was my best one, but, money talks so......




Anders Eliasson -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 5 2007 18:18:35)

Oh, you made a righty... Good. Thats ambitious.[:D] I´m glad you sold it. Guitars are made to be played. And I´m sure you´ll make a better one soon.

Righty or lefty? (Sounds like american politics[&:])




PeterB -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 5 2007 18:57:34)

I, too, am left-handed, and have not noticed any real difference from playing converted right-hand guitars. It makes sense that asymmetrical bracing would affect the sound, but it hasn't been noticeable to my ear. I don't really know about the long-term effect on the soundboard, however.

Peter




TANúñez -> RE: Influence of Lefthandconversion (Mar. 5 2007 19:59:52)

quote:

Oh, you made a righty... Good. Thats ambitious. I´m glad you sold it. Guitars are made to be played. And I´m sure you´ll make a better one soon.


Thanks. I just don't want to become a collector of my own guitars. I hope this next one will be better, then I won't feel as sad for letting my last one go.




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET