srshea -> RE: Moron style - Tabs material ? (Jan. 7 2007 23:16:12)
|
legrec, I purchased Evan Harrar’s (the gypsyflamenco.com guy) Diego book as well as the rhythm lesson last year and I’m very happy with what I got. The question as to whether or not this material is worth the high price seems to come up pretty frequently, and I myself balked at the price before finally buying the stuff. Whatever reservations I had vanished once I got the package. The transcription book is quite long, 400+ falestas, I think) and it came with five CDs of Diego’s playing as well as a disc of Harrar playing the falsetas in the order they appear in the book. It’s true that this stuff isn’t cheap, but most flamenco transcription books aren’t: the Worms/Faucher books run about 45-50 bucks each- but when you consider the quantity and quality of the material involved I think it’s worth it. If you’re really serious about learning to play Diego’s music, not just picking up a few falestas here and there but really immersing yourself in the style, then this is as good as you’re going to find as far as self study goes. Start saving! However, having said all that, I should point out that what you’re going to learn from the gypsyflamenco material (ideally) is how to play Diego’s stuff as he played it. If you want to play like Carlos Beccera in the sample that flamencoguru posted, I’m not really sure how far Harrar’s book is going to get you in that direction. To my ears that sample has a much different feel and rhythmic approach than Diego’s actual playing (the video clip that flamencoguru posted last summer is quite a bit closer, I think), which isn’t to say it’s good or bad, better or worse- just considerably different. Since you’ve already made plans to travel to Moron you might want to see if you can get Beccera’s contact info from flamencoguru and then try and make arrangements to meet up and study with him. Straight to the source. Ain’t no transcription book in the world that can beat learning from the guy who you want to play like! Good luck.
|
|
|
|