Miguel de Maria -> RE: sticking points for speed (Jul. 23 2006 15:24:13)
|
Okay, to take a new tact... Grisha has proven that he can still execute the technique on a severely modified guitar. He told us he can play ANY guitar (and I believe him). This is highly different from my current situation. My guitar has high or normal tension strings, low action, and a very nice feel to it. Whe I play other guitars, my performance is very much downgraded. For example, my friend plays an Ovation with extra high tension strings. The moment I pick that guitar up, I put it right back down. Yeech! I can't play it, it feels like reaching inside a piano. I think most of us that are trying to play decently complicated things find that string tension does matter. I wonder if that points the fact that we're just not that good, or does it mean there's something specific we should be working on? Lately I've realized an important point: you have to be able to control the moment of release of the RH note, and you have to be able to synchronize the action of playing RH and LH exactly. Going further, if you are going to play fast, you need to be able to touch the string and release it in an instant, an instant you can control, and then relax. I know of no other way to play at speed. So, we could see string tension interfering with this in a few ways: 1. needing more strength to release string 2. rubbery feeling somehow "sticking" on finger 3. increasing strength/time needed to push down LH It seems to me that someone like Grisha is able to adjust to these factors, through experience and greater sensitivity (he is a very sensitive guy--I bought his album and he looks very sensitive on it :)). It might be a good exercise for regular guys to look at these factors and see how much of it we can counteract through a little use of the mind. When I play over the hole, my string can easily pass through with no effort, but as I move toward the bridge, it begins to "catch". Part of this is because my fingernail may not be attacking the string properly. It may be at an angle that will _pull_ the string. Think, it is only a tiny light piece of nylon, but if you _pull_ on it, you could probably lift the whole guitar. But if you find a way to _slide_ through it, you can do it with much less strength. A low tension string will let you get away with less strength or a less than perfect angle. A higher tension string will make you work real hard, especially until you examine the problem and refine your attack. I hypothesize that not only does Grisha have a perfect attack, he is strong. So, no problem. The problems with low tension strings are a little harder to analyze. Probably one of them is that eventually, your fingers will catch if you are not using a perfect attack. It is fine until you try to go fast, when this problem "catches up" to you. Another is that you are just not used to it. If you are always relying on that tension, it woudl take time to adjust to a more floppy feeling. You might find yourself adjusting your hand position or attack slightly. As far as the LH goes, a higher tension string makes it harder to push down. So you need to have the ability to exert more force in the same amount of time. This seems to me to be a strength issue. Recall that as the task gets harder, we tend to use more and larger muscles. A light touch with one finger can easily be done, but a powerful blow calls upon the whole arm or body. This is natural, but lessens independence among the fingers. The prescription for this, it would seem would be gradual strengthening of the fingers individually through lots of slurs or perhaps playing on a high-action guitar while respecting the independent action of the fingers. To those who are still reading, I would like to reiterate that I think it's important for the RH to be able to play a note in an instant, any instant. If you can gain enough control without clenching up your hand, the speed will easily follow once your mind can think the notes.
|
|
|
|