Left hand index finger problem (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - General: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=13
- - - Left hand index finger problem: http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=36473



Message

fevictor -> Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 0:30:07)

I have an issue with my my finger:

I find that it naturally wants to straighten itself out completely when I'm not using it, obviously causing it to be too far away from the strings. When I try to straighten it, I find that I can't! I'll do my scales with just middle and ring fingers, or pinky and ringer fingers, and the index is like a flagpole - completely straight. This morning I wrapped black tape around it to keep it bent while I did my scales, but when I removed the tape my finger straightened out again. I have no mental control at all! Its quite frustrating.

Has anybody gone thru this? Can you recommend any excersise?

Thanks in advance.



Miguel de Maria -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 0:53:22)

One thing that might help is to use total attention on the finger. There is a state of extreme attentiveness, where you even lose any attachment to whether you succeed or fail in your task, that may help.

I am trying to get rid of a bad habit myself. When I play long descending scales, my hand tightens up when I do a string skip with the m finger. I am trying to do it really slow and keep that correct sensation.

Another one is called negative learning. Play the scale and intentionally cause it to do what it naturally does. In this way you may gain control of the action and be able to sense it more easily. All these techniques require a lot of focus, with little room for other thoughts in your head.



fevictor -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 0:58:11)

Sounds good Miguel...I like the negative learning idea, I'll try it tonight. I sure haven't had any luck the positive way[:)]



edgar884 -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 1:13:11)

Do chromatic exercises and try to leave your left hand fingers down as long as possible before each note change.[:)]



fevictor -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 1:23:01)

Thanks Edgar, but I do that excersise all the time. I'm just now starting to do the chromatic scales without including the index finger, and thats how I came across the problem.



edgar884 -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 2:43:28)

Yes but when you do it don't move your fingers until needed. Most people don't quite get this. JUst doing chromatic won't get the same results. You have to hold down your fingers.
So if your not using your index it still needs to float right obove the fret even though it isn't being played.
So left hand, 1234 next string 1 while 234 stay then 2 while 34 stay ect: it should look like a crab crawling up the neck.

Or this one works if that doesn't work hold the g string fingers down and move your index only. Then move to the next finger holding 134 while moving only your 2 finger. Make sure the hand doesn't move but the index goes from straight to bent.

---------------------------------1----------------------------------------
---------------1--------1--------------------------------------------------
---(2-3-4)--------------------------------------------------------------------
------------1------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------1--------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------1---------------------------------------------------------------

This will fix it for sure, the other key is to do it as slowly as humanly possible.

I hope I made sense on that.

Or legato only. All hammerons at slow speed.

------------------------------------------------3 5 6--------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------3-5-6--------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------2-3-5--------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------2-3-5---------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------1 3-5----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----1-3-5------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Focus on suspending the index over i'ts specified note(as close as possible)it won't work unless you do it at a very slow tempo.

sorry bro, for all that. it should help.



fevictor -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 3:10:27)

Don't be sorry....thats great info! I actually always do the chromatic scales the way you described; not moving my finger untill I have to. But I'll try the other excersises and your suggestions. Thanks[:)]



edgar884 -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 3:44:57)

Ok just checking most people don't practice them that way.

Thanx take care man.[:)]



Ricardo -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 16:03:11)

quote:

straighten itself out completely when I'm not using it,


When you are NOT using it? I don't think there is anything I have ever played where I did not use the index at all. Unless you mean a certain passage of music or exercise? You should use the finger all the time. For an exercise or certain chord, I would not worry so much about it. I mean when playing a normal piece or scale, it shoots straight out after it was used? But comes down again next time it plays right? I need to see a vid to be sure. Watch yourself play in the mirror, that helps me alot. I play a Bb9 chord in first position with open strings ringing, and I dont' use index with the traditional capo. The index shoots out deliberately as you described so it does not hit the peg.

You can also work on playing scales under the barre, where index is down always as the other fingers play. That is very common in flamenco. My index is up and down all the time.

Play this and tell me what is your index finger doing. It must play the second fret notes, but watch it in the mirror:

E-----------2---------------2-------------
B--2-3-5------5-3-2-3-5-----5-3-2--etc
G------------------------------------------
D-------------------------------------------
A--------------------------------------------
E---------------------------------------------

If it jumps back and forth between strings, but you can keep the rhtyhm even, that is fine. If it shoots out straight when it jumps, it will slow you down, so increase the speed and see if it starts to behave. Some would play this by laying the index flat across both strings. That solves the index problem. Try it both ways.

Ricardo



Miguel de Maria -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (Apr. 30 2006 17:22:16)

Victor,
I just got a little success with my problem and maybe it will help you. A lot of times it is hard to "not" do something, so you should instead replace it with "doing" something. In other words, maybe you can't make your finger not straighten out, but you can make it curl or move where it needs to be next.

You may recall I have been having a problem with descending scales, my a finger curls up, tensing my m finger and sappings its strength and accuracy. Well, I just concentrated on the feeling of using the m finger when necessary--paying attention to that specific point--and the problem has started to ease. So instead of telling the m finger, "naughty don't do that", I gave it "something constructive to do".

By the way, I just got back from Vancouver a few days ago. That is one seriously beautiful city. It didn't even rain while I was there, and it was warm! The air is so clean and clear, and the people very nice. I want to move there!



fevictor -> RE: Left hand index finger problem (May 2 2006 21:11:21)

I've been away from the computer for a couple of days....Thanks for the advice Ricardo, I'll try your excersise also. I have seen a tiny improvement since trying the suggestions, but I must say that Miguels is the one that is helping the most. By the way Miguel, don't let Vancouver fool you; Its a beatifullcity thise time of year, but go back in January or February, then let me know how it went!! Seriously.[:)]



Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET