How to freely play virtuosic material? (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - General: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=13
- - - How to freely play virtuosic material?: http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=364089



Message


metalhead -> How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 29 2026 13:59:18)

Now that a lot of what I play is by Vicente/Nunez and the likes, there's a tiny thought that occurs while playing in the back of my mind that says that "I am pretending to be the mighty guys, which I'm obviously not".

Have you any of you ever experienced this?

That gets on my nerves, and I play worse as a result. Any advice how to freely play their music without the added pressure?




Ricardo -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 30 2026 11:39:42)

You have to embrace the fact that when PDL played Montoya, niño Ricardo, sabicas, Escudero and Esteban de Sanlucar covers in his early career, he also fell short of the mark of the maestros. It is recognizable to all the fans of the older guys. One could say the changes in SOME cases were improvements, but in others it was too different from the original to be considered "correct". Well guess what....in BOTH cases that is where the true artist "paco de Lucia" revealed himself.

As Steve vai once said, we sometimes have to "lose ourselves in the identity of another artist we are copying" to understand who WE truly are. It is the mistakes and things that make us our own unique artist. So as you continue to try to improve or do it closer and closer to "correct" you find your own voice, and as you do you should accept that.




Stu -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 30 2026 13:18:26)

quote:

Have you any of you ever experienced this?


I've experienced a lot of things, some kind of variation on this is one of those things.

I've also experienced frustration, doubts, anger, pain! hopelessness as well as joy, excitement, achievement etc.

quote:

Any advice how to freely play their music without the added pressure?


What pressure? from youself? or from the flamenco gods? or are you playing concerts? so audience pressure?

The added pressure of playing something composed by a great maestro??

I feel like maybe you're taking yourself/flamenco too seriously?
This is your music to play and study and enjoy as much as it is mine or anyones.

Of course I sometimes (for a fleeting moment) put myself in the maestros shoes and wish I could play like them etc or have their way of life? ...(tecnically brilliant flamenco guitarist living in jerez and doing gigs and touring with my band)...sure.

maybe just remind yourself... youre nothing, uselss and will never be fit to wipe gerardos shoes??[:D]
"true freedom comes when we realise we are utterly and mercilessly ****ed"

The worst feeling I've ever had is thinking you're doing well and playing great and then meeting a player a 3rd of your age whos 10 times better.
Or watching a maestro, up close in person, play their famous piece.(that youve been trying to learn) and walking away going "oh god I'll never be able to play that like that!"

mentally destroys you for a few days but ultimately leaves you humble and realistic and happy with that.




metalhead -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 30 2026 13:59:52)

I can see what you're trying to get at, but reinforcing the very same hierarchy and calling yourself incapable of wiping somebody's shoes doesn't exactly sound like the way to go. Whatever works for you, I guess.




metalhead -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 30 2026 14:04:14)

I think this is a much more useful perspective. Thanks Ricardo. The only minor problem is that when I try to change their material, it just sounds wrong to me.

Their compositions feel so pristine perfect that even a minor deviation tends to remove the greatness of the piece.




orsonw -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 30 2026 16:48:59)

quote:

...continue to try to improve or do it closer and closer to "correct" you find your own voice, and as you do you should accept that.


Teenager Jesus de la Estrella continues making his way the past few years. Here last friday in Madrid at Suma Flamenca Joven.





Harry -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Sep. 30 2026 23:58:56)

if you are feeling pressure of some kind, consider getting a book like Effortless Mastery. There is some good advice there about mindset.

It really is all about the joy of making a sound that makes sense, and there is no need to attach value or identity or anything like this. Everything should disappear ideally and you just watch yourself playing almost not knowing how it is done.

Although when one is not playing, perhaps there is pressure and judgment and so on.




rombsix -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 1 2026 2:15:03)

quote:

The only minor problem is that when I try to change their material, it just sounds wrong to me.


Even the maestros themselves changed how they play their material over time. You're still very young. I think as you age, you'll become more forgiving of yourself. [:)]




Stu -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 5 2026 9:28:30)

quote:

calling yourself incapable of wiping somebody's shoes



Oh. You've misread. I didn't say I wasnt fit to wipe their shoes, I said YOU weren't! [:D]

[;)]

You've failed to define where the 'pressure' is coming from.

Maybe it's me misunderstanding posts again....

But what's the actual problem? Is it a mental issue? You feel like you aren't doing their great pieces justice and you are beating yourself up, causing you to not be able to play them??

And why are you trying to change their pieces?? Cos a certain passage is difficult??


quote:

mentally destroys you for a few days but ultimately leaves you humble and realistic and happy with that.
.....also to add to this.... it also motivates and strengthens me and makes me more determined! (after the feelings of gloom dissapear![:D]




metalhead -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 5 2026 11:51:07)

I read it perfectly fine. Your advice is unhelpful and frankly speaking, unnecessarily hostile.




Ricardo -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 5 2026 12:10:50)

quote:

ORIGINAL: metalhead

I read it perfectly fine. Your advice is unhelpful and frankly speaking, unnecessarily hostile.


you started off with a subjective "I am pretending to be the mighty guys, which I'm obviously not" and asked others for commiserate examples which Stu gave. Now you are attacking him for doing that.

Simply put, when you change the music and recognize that you did something negative to the original, it is your personal taste at work, which is being informed by your ever increasing knowledge on the tradition. As soon as you deviate you recognize you went off the rails and lost the authenticity. Paco explains it exactly thus: "I don't know what it is...but I know when it is missing". In that particular case he was talking about young guitar players that have not had enough experience with cante and such, and are trying to do their own composing etc.

As I said, you get better at this along the way and even your tastes might change a little that something you feel needs to be exactly like Vicente today, you might want to swap out for something more traditional of Manuel Morao or whoever. At least that is what typically happens. Look at Jeronimo Maya....the young kid had the most progressive weird modern toque and today he plays more like his old man. Those that are serious about flamenco follow this path, almost by design.




Stu -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 5 2026 14:25:06)

[:o]In the words of Snagglepuss the Lion.....Heavens to Murgatroyd!!

Hostile advice?... seems paradoxical to me.

I read this...
quote:

Your advice is unhelpful and frankly speaking, unnecessarily hostile.

...and think of this.
quote:

I feel like maybe you're taking yourself/flamenco too seriously?



I know this never works....but chill out man. [:D] It's all love! When I use laughing and winky emojis it means I'm attempting to have a bit of fun and make jokes.

I asked you several questions (in both my posts) to try and understand your issue more, but you haven't answered any. So I resort to humour.... but I see its failed.

Good luck with your feelings of inadequecy![&:]




devilhand -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 5 2026 21:54:07)

quote:

ORIGINAL: metalhead

Now that a lot of what I play is by Vicente/Nunez and the likes, there's a tiny thought that occurs while playing in the back of my mind that says that "I am pretending to be the mighty guys, which I'm obviously not".

Have you any of you ever experienced this?

That gets on my nerves, and I play worse as a result. Any advice how to freely play their music without the added pressure?

You're thinking too much. Just play and enjoy.




metalhead -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 7 2026 20:53:32)

In that case, I apologize for not getting the humor.




Mark2 -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 9 2026 6:13:14)

The only way to freely play virtuosic music is to be a virtuoso. That’s where being honest with yourself comes into play. Recording yourself is paramount to discovering and accepting your actual level. Not that you have to be satisfied with your current level but be honest about your ability to transmit emotion with the material you want to play. If you can’t dominate the material it’s going to be difficult to make people feel something. I’ve heard so many people, some quite accomplished, playing Vicente or Paco stuff without managing to transmit much at all. If you are playing primarily for your own pleasure by all means learn and play what you want to the best of your ability. If you are playing to please an audience or other performers it’s helpful to realize that the simplest material played well gets the ole more often than super complicated stuff. Exception being super strong and fast picado.That usually does the job. It seems even casual listeners recognize the brilliance of that particular technique




Arash -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 9 2026 10:43:18)

Just change your Maestro to Ottmar, take off your socks while playing, and become a mighty virtuoso instantly.[sm=Smiley Guitar.gif]




rombsix -> RE: How to freely play virtuosic material? (Oct. 9 2026 13:24:29)

quote:

Just change your Maestro to Ottmar, take off your socks while playing, and become a mighty virtuoso instantly.


[:D][8D]




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET