|
Andy Culpepper -> RE: Picked up a 1962 Conde (Sep. 27 2026 2:53:32)
|
quote:
my apologies this thread has gone off the rails it seems with this topic. I think confirmation bias is the main issue that is affecting the definitions of this topic. If you play a certain way, harder or softer by your subjective experience of the sound coming out, you will automatically assume the pulsacion is causing this, and then the variables that change you then believe are the "cause". Like you get a brighter response and feel working less the guitar is softer when all that happened was the frequency response. Same if the guitar is too humid and dries out or vice versa. Then you have people wrongly believing that the guitar is built inherently with these characteristics and a new bias is established "I need a stiff pulsacion like this old Conde", and etc. My personal experience of guitar response got orders of magnitude less complicated when I recognized the statement by Amalia Ramirez that we can change this with the action adjustment at the saddle. Bingo, but perhaps it is my own confirmation bias but erasing that problem makes the situation very clear and easy to address. I don't think the "pulsacion" is *causing* the guitar to feel like it needs to be played harder or softer, I think that feeling of needing to be played harder or softer just *is the definition* of pulsacion. I'll be the first to admit that I'm not the best player in the world but I definitely encounter certain guitars that just are physically more demanding to play for the right hand. Like these guitars will even chip the krazy glue off my nails faster than most. The guitar may even feel and respond like I'm playing close to the bridge when I'm actually half way toward the soundhole. It's actually somewhat rare to encounter guitars like that, I would say like 90% of the guitars I try just feel "normal" but there are certain outliers. Now I will say that setup DEFINITELY plays a role in this, it's possible it may even be the biggest factor. A guitar with a higher action will tolerate and require more force to produce the raspy, hard-driven sound that most of us look for when we play flamenco. The string height at the bridge I think is less of a factor for this particular phenomenon, my guitar is fairly low there (7.5mm) but still has that stiffer feel. But of course that matters for certain things like golpes and such.
|
|
|
|