thomazozo -> RE: Luthiers - Whose opinion matters most? (Apr. 2 2024 19:21:20)
|
That is hilarious [:D] As an artist and art professor, I find a connection with your posts, particularly when you share insights into your educational background. I often advise my students that they may need to create art that might not resonate with their grandmother's tastes or understanding... When it comes to art dealers, their evaluations can sometimes be a cause for concern. My observation in the art world suggests that dealers typically represent artworks they believe they can sell. Therefore, their assessment often reflects the potential for sales rather than the inherent quality of the work. I assume this parallels the guitar world, however there may be worlds of difference between types of artwork, and not so much between guitars. I would relish the opportunity to delve into "private gossip"—essentially, exploring the nuanced qualities of musical instruments through the eyes of a luthier or a musician who possesses a distinct perspective on what constitutes quality. It's a challenge to find precise and meaningful descriptions of the characteristics and sound qualities of instruments. The terms "good classical" or "good flamenco" guitar, for instance, fall short of conveying the rich array of attributes an instrument may have. Also many descriptions seem to veer into exaggeration, as not to offend. While I acknowledge that there may not be definitive answers to my queries, I'd like to see reviews and evaluations that offer a more nuanced perspective, such as acknowledging that a guitar is excellent but not suited to the reviewer's personal taste. Such insights, coupled with a more thorough explanation of the reasons behind this assessment might be more valuable. Honestly, if I had the chance to experience a variety of flamenco guitars firsthand, my curiosity might venture into a different subset of questions. However, without the means to visit a place abundant with these instruments, I'm relegated to conjuring up their quality from photos and recordings found online.
|
|
|
|