estebanana -> RE: Where to get an 8 string flamenco guitar? (Dec. 17 2014 0:13:39)
|
quote:
I am more traditionalist like you, but honestly the 33% is not right as majority of the time we are "adding" bass strings to the guitar and those strings tend to be essentially 6th strings tuned down in pitch with significantly reduced tensions. If we add a higher string then, more often, a high E would break long before compromising the guitar itself (In my experience). The added tension is not measured in percentages, it is measured in pounds of pressure. You can't do the tension to structure calculation work in the design unless you have hard numbers on string tension. And you are correct Ricardo being that lower tension basses are added, the guitar can sustain the added tension without much modification. The average Conde' with a slightly thicker top can handle it fine. The real place it needs the bit of help is the first transverse brace above the sound hole. That one needs to be beefy to keep the neck body connection integrity, it takes a lot of loading. And the neck itself is important, but with carbon fiber spars the neck can be fabricated to remain stiff and straight. Adding one lower bass on a seven string, I use d'Darrio silver overwound 0.54 or 0.56, creates an average of 15 lbs of added tension when tuned between D and low C, tuning to low B or A is possible, but at that low pitch the string is not adding significant loading to the bridge. The general rule is, as pitch goes down and string diameter goes thicker, tension drops. One string at 0.56 tuned to D or lower and distributed over the bridge through the top, using carbon fiber and making the transverse bar robust you can safely leave the top graduations the same as any medium built flamenco guitar. And adding two basses increases the loading by double, but again it is moderated by the pitch and string diameter as well as being distributed by the bridge. You have to find out the numbers in pounds of pressure and make calculations based on the strength of the woods you'll be using and the bracing design. Speaking of tuning, a flamenco or any intended use extended range guitar with 7 to 10 strings could also use a kind of 'reentrant' tuning. Many ten string players use one of several type of reentrant tuning schemes. Here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reentrant_tuning Yepes tuning: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten-string_classical_guitar_of_Yepes#Tunings You can study those Wiki entries and see that tunings do not always descend in regular diatonic order, they can be broken into many different combinations of chromatic, diatonic and reentrant possibilities. Tuning orders are a source of never ending discussion for extended range guitarists when they talk about how to match a tuning to a certain piece they want to play, like piano transcriptions. Or how different tunings effect the overtone production of a particular instrument, or even for composing where the composer wants to utilize specific pedal tones, etc. The famous 'Brahms Guitar' designed by David Rubio for Paul Galbraith is an extended range guitar with 8 strings which was designed to sustain a low A string and be able to play piano transcriptions. We have to remember David Rubio began as a flamenco guitarist, then a flamenco guitar builder and then he eventually became a violinmaker. So if you have an inclination to use an extended range guitar, maybe your own musical compass is being limited by the genre of flamenco and you need move outside. Sometimes we don't see that life is about making connections to the next thing and instead we grasp to make something work in the wrong genre, musically speaking. If you are drawn to a certain sound of instrument and it does not fit cleanly into the genre you are working in then you have the choice to follow the sound and transcend the genre, or let that go and deepen your roots in one genre. Both ways are legitimate ways to grow. I have seen players contemplate taking on extended range guitars and these questions arise over and over. You can only answer them for your self. You can also experiment with reentrant tunings on your present six string guitar. That may not be a practical way of doing flamenco, but if you think back to the Baroque guitar where there is still a lot of rasgueado in the music, you can consider that it uses a form of reentrant tuning. The rasgeo and the reentrant tuning are historically concurrently played. This may not be regular flamenco tuning, but in experimenting with non standard tunings you may learn more about chord voicing in standard tuning. It's my understanding that many of the flamenco guitarists we know at the top of the game have used non standard tunings and have gone back and forth between standard and non standard and moved falseta material over the tuning borders. As far as longevity of extended range guitar structures I did some research work on that. I calculated the string tensions and then did the cross referencing with some makers who had practical experience over a period of more than 30 years with extended range guitars and everyone agreed that is was a workable plan at tensions I found to create a flamenco structured seven string. And I have built four of them to date and all were very successful and are being played by customers who are pleased with them. The fifth as I mentioned is classical and the top and braces reflect a more structured top. That guitar does not have a flamenco sound or feel as is was made with a stiff modified lattice structure. It does have a sweet sound, amazing intonation and no wolfy notes. It was made for a composer to record his own music with. I'm mentioning these things to clear up misconceptions that people seem to have about the structures and the potential of extended range guitars whether they intend them to be for flamenco, jazz , bossa nova-choro, or classical music. They do not have to be over built if they are strengthened in the key areas I cited. The Chinese are making ten string and other extended range guitars and you can also get a factory made 7 string from Brazil, they are almost all chunky and heavy, which I suspect is because a factory made guitar is not as finely calibrated as a hand made guitar. I have studied those guitars and determined they are over built. My aim was to create a high performance guitar with an extended range that was built to the edge of a performance maximum while still structured to last more than a lifetime. I think I did pretty good. And to date I don't recall another makers who frequent the Foro except for Stephen Eden and Jorge who have made any extended range guitars. The later man Jorge asked me for a consult in designing his model and it came out very nice. When someone makes and sells more extended range flamenco guitars than I have and does more research than I have, I'll take advice from them. On the other hand, I still like six string guitars and always have, but I'm not here to put guitar players in jail by saying this or that is not possible. I have never supported that kind of attitude even though I generally have a bad attitude about a great many things. I'm just a bitter old fart, but allowing players to make the kind of music they need to make is not one my attitude problems.
|
|
|
|