RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - Product Reviews: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=27
- - - RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano: http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=209248



Message

tri7/5 -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 22 2012 20:36:35)

Makes sense to me. I know it's much easier to get an accurate feel for compas in standard notation for me personally.



RTC -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 26 2012 3:32:55)

quote:

The estilos basicos are the examples of compas, where you must understood the compas...and the better solution is write this in music and see and listen the record of this estilos by Paco...
We haven't negative basic about this...and we think like Paco that in music the campas is the only possibility to understood..


I respect Paco's desire, and being his video he can do as he feels it's best.

BUT:

I am completely unable to understand your explanation, and for those of us that do not read music we will just have to do with what was provided. Witch to me is a big shortfall of a instructional DVD. Flamenco guitar is all about "compas", and when you deprive us from such important information we can not utilize this instructional DVD to it's potential. I do not see what harm would have done to have included tab in that section.

For those that have not purchase this DVD, and can not read music, be aware of the fact that the section on "compas" does not contain Tab. I was disappointed.



Guitart Flamenco -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 26 2012 16:12:54)

The Paco's compas video is very very simple and clear - so you can be sure that you don't need the transcription of this.
Untill 11 november 2012 if you buy the DVD you will have a fantastic Savarez Tomatito flamenco set string!



Munin -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 27 2012 13:08:10)

Do people really pick up compás sections from tabs? I don't understand why you would need that, since the notes will be just a couple chords you know already anyway, while the rhythm is notated (and would be notated exactly the same way for tab as well) or can/should be picked up from the video. So I don't understand how tab would help in this case?



n85ae -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 27 2012 14:28:50)

Well, the answer is YES people do pick up Compas sections from Tab and
here's why.

I can read music, but I find it exceedingly difficult to do on the guitar
so when I first discovered TAB I thought this is fantastic. It can be written just
like standard notation, BUT with strings and fret position. Wow wonderfull!
Finally I don't have waste all my time trying to figure out which note is where
on the fretboard.

Yes it may be that if the chord is indicated, then TAB is not necessary but
I still find that TAB included makes it much easier for clarification.

I don't understand this argument that it is better for showing Compas to use
standard notation. You could/should do both, right? Then there is no more
difficulty for anybody. The people offended by tab can just get out some masking
tape and cover the tab ... Or perhaps duct tape ... :)

(Sorry for the sarcasm but the argument against tab seems silly).

In any case - I do like Paco's stuff, and have his older course which I still
look at. I would likely buy this newer one as well, BUT not if it's not using
tab.

Regards,
Jeff



mezzo -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 27 2012 14:50:38)

for me the answer is NO.
In my case tabs are usefull only to get the notes. Once I understand the fretting, I always and only refer to the audio or video recording to pick up the groove.

That's why I think that some books like the "duende flamenco" series (C. Worms) are worthless for me. You have all the falsetas tabbed but then the audio references included are only in a discographic manner. In most of the case, if I want to learn a falseta from these books, I'll need to listen the original audio.

I don't have the book discussed here, but what if the teacher demonstrate the strumming with apagado (mutted string)?



kudo -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 27 2012 22:58:18)

I orderd my copy a few days ago, lets see when it gets here! [:)]



n85ae -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 28 2012 1:13:23)

I agree with this, the tabs to find the notes, and really listening is the only
way to understand how to play it.

Jeff

quote:

for me the answer is NO.
In my case tabs are usefull only to get the notes. Once I understand the fretting, I always and only refer to the audio or video recording to pick up the groove.

That's why I think that some books like the "duende flamenco" series (C. Worms) are worthless for me. You have all the falsetas tabbed but then the audio references included are only in a discographic manner. In most of the case, if I want to learn a falseta from these books, I'll need to listen the original audio.

I don't have the book discussed here, but what if the teacher demonstrate the strumming with apagado (mutted string)?



Guitart Flamenco -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Oct. 28 2012 7:11:07)

To make clear with all the readers the 32 falsetas recorded are in notation and tablature, only the compas for decision of Paco are only in notation...



mark indigo -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Nov. 9 2012 19:26:47)

what guitar is Paco playing in the video? who is the maker?



Guitart Flamenco -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Nov. 9 2012 20:01:06)

Manuel Reyes...



mark indigo -> RE: Manual de la guitarra flamenca by P. Serrano (Nov. 10 2012 16:51:49)

quote:

Manuel Reyes...


thanks for the info, i thought maybe it was, but wanted to be sure.



Page: <<   <   1 [2]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET