Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - General: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=13
- - - Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time?: http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=139



Message


Escribano -> Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 11 2003 23:39:18)

My 4 finger is much stronger than my 5, do many guitarists favour 4 over 5 as a bad habit?




Phil -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 12 2003 1:18:41)

Simon,
I don't think it makes any difference as long as the timing is correct. One of the first things my teacher told me is that rasqueados and alzpua are very personal. That is to say, each person does them differently. The important thing is how they sound. He didn't teach me ras and up until now he hasn't said anything derogatory about mine.

I am practicing the ras that he seems to use more than any other: p (up), m (down), p (down). His fingers appear to be relaxed but he keeps the M and P at a fixed distance and all the action comes from twisting the wrist. He barely touches the strings most of the time (brushing the strings would be a good discription) and he can pop it in any place and it's always perfect. I've noticed that most of the guitarists in this area (Jerez) use this ras. You can do a super fast quadruplet or a long continuous ras with this technique. He also does the a,m,i, i (up) a lot and interchanges it with the other one. I'm not sure if he uses e,a,m,i, i (up), it's hard to tell by watching, I'll have to ask him. But these are the only two that I've seen him use. So it apparent that you don't need to learn a lot of different ones.

I hope this helps.
Phil




Merle -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 12 2003 1:23:46)

Well, I'm just a beginner, Simon, and I'll tell you, there is a difference in a 4 stroke or 5 stroke rasqueo...you just need to know where they FIT.

I have found out that just ONE SIMPLE finger stroke, up, down, 4 or 5, can completely throw you off compas! So, you need to fit in the 4 or 5 where it is jives with the compas! ;>)

Merle




Thomas Whiteley -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 12 2003 2:31:03)

Simon;

I have posted more than the average person has when it comes to playing rasgueados. After all, I have 101 Rasgueados available on my web site.

Some teachers and players will insist there are only a few rasgueados. The rasgueado is typically specific to a region of Spain and also dependent upon the palo being played. Additionally, people have different construction of their hands and this will enter into the use of rasgueados.

Like Phil said it is really about timing. You can develop several rasgueados and use them as needed. If you play for dancers you may want to use a loud approach. Cante requires a different touch and in solo playing just about anything goes – depending upon who the audience is!

For many players a simple indice up and down done well is better than any attempt to “show off”. First get the basic compas under your belt and introduce different rasgueados to get the feeling you want. Be sure to record yourself over time and label the date and what you are doing. It will be a great record to see how you are advancing and developing.




Escribano -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 12 2003 18:07:34)

Thanks, I should have said stroke rather than finger




Miguel de Maria -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 13 2003 13:03:35)

At my school, they use the a m i i quite often. Tino explained to me that using the five stroke compas makes it difficult to get an even sound in most palos, but that it´s good to use in Soleares. I think what he meant is that beats with 4 strikes in it sound more even, more regular. Actually you can easily see this in comparing flamenco and classical tremolo, the 4 beat classical sounds very linear while the 5 beat flamenco quite round and full. Perhaps in compas you want more discrete sounds.

It seems that Tino uses this amii for compas, such as in Alegrias (starting on 1) amii amii 3 amii amii 6 amii 8 and 10 11 12. Tino doesn´t use marote style ras very much, for his continuous ras he seems to favor iai, i up a down i down. Of course, as Tom said these are both personal and regional. These are as much Tino´s choices as anything Sevilla would represent, I believe. last night at the Festival at Moguer (where I saw Antonio Canales, and Chocolate accompanied by my teacher Eduardo Rebollar among others!) I noticed that each guitarist seems to have his own favorites. One guy Nino Jero or something, seemed to use Marote style ras for almost everything. He played really hard, and left lots of spaces in his compas, always coming in on weird beats and always hitting the accents and stops dead on! Very dynamic. He and his singer even played a rumba.

Another very useful ras is the ma down p up ras. This is powerful and can be put into triplets or even beats. Yes, it´s just up and down but it can be done very fast and I think just about every guitarist does it. Plus, it seems to me to be easy, you just have to practice it slow and relax and will come out pretty quick. Seems useful for accompanying dancers, especially when they start going fast.

Another point, is that there seems to be at least two different ways of playing the same ras. There´s the throw and the push. So you play a four stroke ras by flicking, marble style, your fingers are the string. You get a percussive sound, especially when you aim it at the bass strings. However you can also push. Sort of like laying the finger on the string and then pushing it through. That´s another sound, and this is how I have been practicing. It seems to make for a fuller, more lush and rich sound.

While I´m here, I´d also like to share some guitar student secrets. I have been hanging out with a bunch of guys who go to the Paco Pena school, I delight in getting inside information and insights about the master and his program. First thing, when you start for two months you can only play with your thumb. He tells you that for 2 months you must only play with the thumb, and then he shows you how. Supposedly you are supposed to push down and, as if you were trying to push the string into the soundhole! And with your thumb completely relaxed and free of any muscular activation, you use your forearm to push in. I am sure you will find this very interesting Ron. For 2 months you are supposed to do this.

Paco Pena always insists that you play with a very particular sound--his sound. And he insists you always play with a very powerful volume. Phillip, one of the students, says that it´s incredible how loud PP plays, that he has never heard anyone play like that, although PP is a small person. I am going to try to learn how to do the thumb thing, although using your arm to push your thumb sounds like a horrible transgression of the economy of motion principle, if it´s necessary at least I should learn a little of it.


And Finally, it seems that there is a secret to becoming an excellent guitar player--you have to practice! The consensus among my group is that you have to play 5 hours a day. This actually is more than my research, which has said that you have to work 4 hours a day for ten years, to become a virtuoso. And notice I said work, not play... there is a chasm of a difference between those two things.




Escribano -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 13 2003 14:44:31)

Hey thanks for popping in Michael, sweltering in Sevilla? Roll on the evening and the cervezas!

I think I know what you mean about the 5 stroke in the solea but I have to get mine even to work in compas.




Guest -> [Deleted] (Jul. 13 2003 15:39:09)

[Deleted by Admins]




Thomas Whiteley -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 13 2003 16:05:02)

Michael;

Great post! You have brought up some interesting points. I wish I could get together with everyone in one room and discuss this as it is one of my favorite topics.

Quick outline of playing rasgueado variations:

1. Anchor the pulgar against the top of the guitar top or the sixth string or both.
2. Strike the finger tips towards the soundhole.
3. Strike the finger tips towards the bridge.

In looking at all the old flamenco movies I have ever seen, I have the impression that Sabicas used the indice, medio picado while others used pulgar only. Was Sabicas the first or one of the first flamenco guitarists to use I, M picado?

All Spaniards that I have met that play flamenco guitar seem to be 5’ 4” tall. They have small hands that are capable of stretching as far as mine can, and they have tremendous strength. That strength begins in the forearms. I have shaken hands with people like Sabicas, Carlos Montoya, Juan Serrano and Mariano Cordoba. All have (or had) very strong handshakes.

Some pianists I have shaken hands with give you the “dead fish” if you know what I mean.

About using the pulgar first and developing strength: that is what I was taught. I have black belts in judo and karate and the technique of using the forearm to obtain strength through the pulgar is much like what you learn in karate – the force begins behind and point of contact. But the secret is to relax and use the pulgar as an extension of the forearm and not force or tense the arm and hand, which can cause injury.

When I was playing professionally, after three hours of playing I began to feel as if I could begin to do anything I wanted – it was as if my hands were ready and I totally forgot the world. I would then begin to make progress.

I played an average of ten hours a day and then performed an additional one to two hours several days a week. I got to the point that I no longer used the term “practice” as I would just play and enjoy every minute.

I am a great believer in learning technique first and then learn how to play music – regardless of the instrument involved. I play several instruments as well as teach. There are so many ways to play and teach. I have never tried to make one of my students a little Thomas Whiteley. After all, I am 6’ 7” so the way I do things is not the same as the average person. I take into account the physical attributes of the student. I will teach “correct technique”, as well as any of the variations I am aware of, to get my point across to the student. It is up to the student to produce the correct sound.

One final thought that I have expressed previously on another forum. A major reason for so many different approaches to flamenco technique has to do with when flamenco guitar began to become popular. It was a time when there was little communications or media of any sort. People in Spain developed the techniques and were taught from father to son, or from a neighbor.

I found that Barbers in the early 1960’s in Spain would teach flamenco guitar for about 25 cents for one lesson. A haircut was 17 cents and most Spanish men had long hair before there were hippies. A bottle of vino tinto was 3 cents. Teaching guitar was not a bad idea.

Each family had its own techniques,. As well as each neighborhood, and area of the country. Remember the words from Juan Serrano, about the rasgueado he plays? His father taught him! I have not found anyone else performing that rasgueado unless Juan taught them!

Sabicas was from northern Spain and did not have access to flamenco guitarists as people did in the southern part of Spain. So it seems conceivable Sabicas did a number of things on his own as for what technique to use and how to develop it. Perhaps the isolation Sabicas had from the rest of Spain was a good thing as he brought so much to the rest of us to enjoy and learn.

I have at least one thing in common with Paco Pena. We were born the same year! [:)]




Guest -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 13 2003 18:59:55)

Thats right, how about a trplat with the usuall p,m,p, but with a golpe with the up stroke of, anyone use that?




Guest -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 13 2003 19:01:14)

Up stroke of the P, sorry




Guest -> [Deleted] (Jul. 13 2003 20:04:17)

[Deleted by Admins]




Ron.M -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 13 2003 20:42:19)

Michael,
Great and informative post as usual! Keep 'em coming!
On the PP thumb bit.....
My own thumb tech is based on his..(I got a couple of free private lessons from him once when he was up in Edinburgh in the distant past).
The really "hard" thumb technique he uses (ie in the "badass" solo pugar stuff), he keeps the thumb rigid and rotates from the wrist.
In other stuff, like playing arpegio with thumb, he moves the thumb from the base, with no wrist rotation.
Remember, when playing really hard hitting pulgar stuff, an incredible amount of finesse is involved...not just brute force!
Always focus your attention on the edge of the thumbnail, for that's what produces the sound.
You can hit a nail into a block of wood with a hammer as hard as you like, but if you don't have the judgement to hit it absolutely square on...it will bend.

cheers Mike, looking forward to the next instalment!

Ron




Guest -> [Deleted] (Jul. 13 2003 21:00:04)

[Deleted by Admins]




Phil -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 14 2003 17:43:34)

>One guy Nino Jero or something, seemed to use Marote style ras for almost everything. He played really hard, and left lots of spaces in his compas, always coming in on weird beats and always hitting the accents and stops dead on! Very dynamic.

Michael,
Niño Jero and his brother Antonio Jero are a couple of the top accompanists in the Jerez area. What you heard was an excellent example of the Jerez style of playing. That ras that you mentioned is probably p(up), m(down), p(down) and is probably the most used ras by players from Jerez. My teacher uses it constantly and has such control over it that he can use as a delicate little flourish just about anywhere or as a long continuous ras that increases in volume as in a Granaina, for example. Keep on sharing your experiences. I find your posts to be extremely interesting. It sounds like you're soaking up knowledge like a sponge. [:D]
Phil




Miguel de Maria -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 15 2003 13:17:22)

More like a wet sponge, Phil. I have seen maybe 15 flamenco shows in the last month! And I have 2 hours of flamenco history, 4 hours of guitar class a day, as well as up to 5 hours of practice. My hands are so dead that my picado has become a flubbing disgrace, and I forget falsetas as soon as I learn them, like when I meet people and I forget their names before I have let go of their hands!

Anyways, I have a newsflash: previous reports to the contrary, Solea por bulerias and Bulerias por Solea are different! According to my flamenco history teacher, Solea por bulerias is a fast solea, that is, with the letra and melody of solea, while Bulerias por Solea is a slow bulerias, with letra and melody of bulerias. We are talking cante here. This directly contradicts, at least to my understanding, of what Eduardo Rebollar, my teacher told me. He claims that the two are exactly the same. And from what I understand of what he told me, there is a distinct melody for SB.

Now, who´s right, who´s wrong? A review of Sunday´s festival at Moguer (which I attended) said that Eduardo was the best guitarist of the night, accompanying Chocolate! Are we going to believe a history teacher or the best player at a festival? Well what I think is that academians will call something whatever they want... and they are right. That is how things will probably be remembered. But if the musicians speak of something a certain way amongst themselves, then they are right too. Each in his own mileau.




Phil -> RE: Why can't I use a 4 finger ras all the time? (Jul. 15 2003 17:20:40)

quote:

According to my flamenco history teacher, Solea por bulerias is a fast solea, that is, with the letra and melody of solea, while Bulerias por Solea is a slow bulerias, with letra and melody of bulerias.


There are many things about Flamenco that people argue about. A lot of differences arise when people don't realize that there may be different terms for things in different areas or regions. However, having said that, I've never ever ever heard anybody say there is a diference between Solea por Bulerias and Bulerias por Solea. I have always heard that the terms are interchangeable. We need to get Sean and Estela to weigh in on this one.

Phil




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET