what defines flamenco for U?

what defines flamenco for U? (Full Version)

Foro Flamenco: http://www.foroflamenco.com/
- Discussions: http://www.foroflamenco.com/default.asp?catApp=0
- - General: http://www.foroflamenco.com/in_forum.asp?forumid=13
- - - what defines flamenco for U?: http://www.foroflamenco.com/fb.asp?m=108911

[Poll]

what defines flamenco for U?

Cante

37% (13)

Guitar

28% (10)

Baile

8% (3)

Palmas

14% (5)

Jaleo

11% (4)

Total Votes : 35

(last vote on : Jun. 1 2009 14:12:44)

Message

Guest -> what defines flamenco for U? (May 28 2009 8:58:27)
What element is the most essential for the music to be called flamenco?

edguerin -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 28 2009 9:07:04)
Multiple answers are possible

Florian -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 28 2009 9:10:36)
quote: Multiple answers are possible yes i was glad to see that ...so i guess you dont have much respect for cajon ai Sean [:D]? also hair wax, long hair and black shirts [:)]

Ricardo -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 29 2009 7:07:19)
Compas and soniquete

XXX -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 29 2009 7:26:28)
quote: ORIGINAL: Ricardo Compas and soniquete Olé, Ricardo! I was going to say 'rythm' or compas, too bad its not listed... You just have to look closely... Cante is based on... ? Rythm. Toque is based on ... ? Rythm. Baile? Rythm. Palmas, Cajon, Jaleo,... ? Rythm. Rythm, Rythm, Rythm. Of course the libre palos are also flamenco, but they dont "define" flamenco for me.

Pimientito -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 30 2009 3:02:11)
quote: hair wax, long hair and black shirts Dont forget plastic earings and Ducados

Jan Willem -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 30 2009 3:23:24)
Canté, compas/soniquete

Jan Willem -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 30 2009 3:30:52)
quote: You just have to look closely... Cante is based on... ? Rythm. Toque is based on ... ? Rythm. Baile? Rythm. Palmas, Cajon, Jaleo,... ? Rythm. Rythm, Rythm, Rythm. Of course the libre palos are also flamenco, but they dont "define" flamenco for me. IMO Canté is far more essential. Rythm on itself can't project emotions in the same way canté can.

XXX -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 30 2009 4:45:35)
quote: ORIGINAL: Jan Willem IMO Canté is far more essential. Rythm on itself can't project emotions in the same way canté can. That is a question of what attracts you more in flamenco. Singing is in every music form an essential part, but it doesnt "define" the music form for me. (Music is more abstract, i think). Compas is what makes cante/toque/baile flamenco, and what divides them from all other music styles IMO. Each one can stand on their own, if there is compas. You could even have a rock riff, make it fit nicely in compas, and call it buleria.

Ron.M -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 30 2009 10:34:35)
quote: what defines flamenco for U? A Paco guitar. [:D][:D][:D] cheers, Ron PS: Oh..yes.. ...and a signed photo.

Anders Eliasson -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 31 2009 0:09:51)
cante and handmade guitars

mark indigo -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 31 2009 2:37:34)
quote: what defines flamenco for U? A Paco guitar. of course, the maestro of maestro's maestro's invented the flamenco guitar, didn't he....?[8\|][:D][:D][:D]

mark indigo -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 31 2009 2:41:50)
quote: what defines flamenco for U? What element is the most essential for the music to be called flamenco? flamenco "forms" if it's not solea, siguiriyas, bulerias, tangos, tientos, etc. then, to me, it's not flamenco....

at_leo_87 -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (May 31 2009 3:25:46)
quote: flamenco "forms" if it's not solea, siguiriyas, bulerias, tangos, tientos, etc. then, to me, it's not flamenco.... i agree. this is usually how i judge it. some songs/people blur the lines though...

Arash -> RE: what defines flamenco for U? (Jun. 1 2009 12:53:12)
Well, i don't want to jump on the (Cante,etc.) bandwagon and am honest and vote for..... Guitar [:)] But i respect and like Cante, Baile and all other related things very much. But without Guitar, i would leave the world of flamenco.

Page: [1]

Forum Software powered by ASP Playground Advanced Edition 2.0.5
Copyright © 2000 - 2003 ASPPlayground.NET